Agri profit grows over 100pc; tax ratio below 1pc
LAHORE – The agriculture sector contributes over 23 percent to the country’s Gross Domestic Production and yet accounts for less than 1 percent of the government revenues.
The gross profitability for agriculture products such as cotton, sugar and wheat have increased by 100, 63 and 52 percent respectively during the last two years but tax collection from the sector remains minimal despite the fact that it continues to enjoy subsidized inputs and freedom to charge prices above international prices, experts said.
“Since 2008, gross profit earned on all major crops has improved considerably, -cotton 4.5x growth, sugarcane 63 percent, wheat 52 percent and rice 21 percent- whilst taking into account increases in costs, they said.
They observed that the taxation on agriculture sector has always been negligible and the share of federal tax collection from agriculture sector has been only 0.12 percent of GDP in 2003-2004. Noted economist Dr Ashfaq Hassan Khan pointed out that the low share indicated that the entire value-added chain in the agriculture sector is nearly tax-exempted. He argued that although agriculture’s share in national income exceeds 23 percent, revenue raised from the sector is negligible. With limited tax potential of many subsistence farmers, the land revenue system needs to be replaced by agricultural income tax for any significant increase in revenues from this sector.
Experts are of the view that continuous rise in fertilizer prices as well as recently imposed taxation on agriculture inputs are cited as potential drawbacks for agriculture sector. However it is important to understand that over the last 3 years, crop prices have rallied significantly, resulting in improved farm payrolls of late while Further, certain crops such as sugarcane have been known to trade above the notified support price. For example currently it is rumoured that sugarcane prices demanded by farmers is around Rs200 per maund instead of the defined Rs100/maund.
Thus while the rising crop prices is beneficial for inducing modern farming techniques, taxation of some inputs is unlikely to cause any significant dent in crop feasibilities. Furthermore, current price trends indicate that the input-output gap continues to widen which begs the question whether agriculture should continue to enjoy tax benefits and significant subsidies. Given this framework, the recently announced imposition of GST on tractors, fertilizer and pesticides appears to be a step in the right direction –however it is late step, Dr Ashfaq said.
Salman Abduhoo - The Nation




