Taxing agricultural income

Published on December 20, 2010 by admin   ·   2 Comments

Both the
federation and provinces under the
Constitution are bound to follow the definition of “agricultural income”

By Huzaima Bukhari and Dr Ikramul Haq

Taxing agricultural income is the sole prerogative of provincial governments under the 1973 Constitution of Pakistan. These days confusion prevails about the laws in force for levy of income tax on agricultural income.

It is strange to note that politicians, parliamentarians, TV anchors and so-called experts are not clear about these laws. They keep on criticizing federal government for not levying income tax on “agricultural income” without realizing that the fault lies with the provincial governments.

The total collection by all the four provinces under these laws was dismally low in 2009 at just Rs1.89 billion collected against the actual potential of Rs200 billion. The share of agriculture in GDP that year was about 22 percent.

The low collection proves beyond any doubt lack of will to tax the rich absentee landlords in Pakistan; their number is meager but their clout in politics is very strong. This influential class includes the generals and other high-ranking military officers, who now own substantial state land, given to them as awards. They have emerged as a new landed aristocracy. Like barons of feudal Europe, they control our politico-economic system.

Ruthless exploitation of the landless tillers and industrial workers (most of the industries are now also owned by feudal lords in parliament) is the real issue that has never been addressed by any political party.

Presently, the provincial governments are not levying and collecting tax on agricultural income but charging a fixed tax on per-acre basis. The charge is usually Rs150 per acre from the irrigated areas and Rs100 per acre from non-irrigated lands. This acreage-based charge is in gross violation of the Constitution that stipulates tax on agricultural income as defined in Article 260(1).

Entry 47, Part 1 of Federal Legislative List contained in the Fourth Schedule to the Constitution (it remains intact even after the 18th Amendment), empowers the federal government to levy “Taxes on income other than agricultural income”. The expression “agricultural income” is defined in Article 260(1) of the Constitution, which says: “Agricultural income” means agricultural income as defined for the purpose of the law relating to income tax.”

The word “means” signifies that this is an exhaustive definition that binds all the provincial legislatures to levy tax on “agricultural income” as defined in the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001. However, the provinces, instead of following that definition, are levying fixed tax. Nobody has taken note of this gross violation till today.

Both the federation and provinces under the Constitution are bound to follow the definition of “agricultural income” as provided in the Income Tax Law while determining their legislative powers in terms of Article 70(4), Article 141, and Article 142 read with the Fourth Schedule to the Constitution. However, it is a matter of great concern that all the four provinces are perpetually violating the command of the supreme law of Pakistan.

Even a cursory look at laws (and amendments therein from time to time) promulgated by them, to tax “agricultural income” shows that:-

(a)Khyber Pakhtunkhaw has not even provided the definition of “agricultural income” in its Northwest Frontier Province Agricultural Income Tax Ordinance, 1993. The tax levied under the name of “Income Tax” is, in fact, a land tax on the basis of produce index units. This is nothing but a mockery of legislative process. If there was no political will to impose income tax on “agricultural income”, then what was the need to hoodwink the people by calling it Agricultural Income Tax? Since 1993 no government of the province has bothered to correct this anomaly. This shows the level of understanding of Constitutional provisions by our legislators (sic).

(b)The same is the case with Sindh Agricultural Income Tax Act of 1994 as amended from time to time. The PPP government is keen to collect VAT or sales tax on services, which it should as its constitutional right, but it has no desire to tax the rich pirs and waderas. Would this nation be informed how much tax is paid by Chief Minister Qaim Ali Shah, Makhdoom Amin Fahim, and many other feudal-cum-pirs of Sindh on their agricultural income?

(c)The Punjab Agricultural Income Tax of 1997, as amended from time to time, is no exception. No effort was made till 2000 to impose income tax on total income earned from this source. A face-saving device was introduced to levy yet another tax on acre basis at different rates in respect of irrigated and non-irrigated lands. Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif has never bothered to tax rich absentee landlords of his province — many of whom dominate PML(N). Proper legislation should have been made as per Constitution to tax the Khosas, Gilanis, Quershis, Tiwanas, Sardars, Chaudharis, Maliks — just to mention a few. Such taxation could have provided room to initiate a number of meaningful welfare and job-oriented schemes for the have-nots, unlike the gimmick of sasti roti that was not restricted to the needy alone. But certainly, even the Sharifs have no intention to tax the rich and mighty feudals. They themselves have joined this class by grabbing many lucrative lands. See palatial palaces in Jati Umra, flats in Mayfair London, property in Saudi Arabia, Dubai and elsewhere.

(d)In Baluchistan, the position is no different. From 1993 to 1999, the Governor of Balochistan promulgated various Agricultural Income Tax Ordinances that were amended from time to time, following the same pattern as in the other three provinces.

The above analysis shows that none of the four provinces, while levying income tax on “agricultural income” followed Article 260(1) of the Constitution. All the agricultural income tax laws passed by them are superficial whereas in substance no tax on “agricultural income” has been imposed by any province, showing an attitude of contempt and apathy towards the Constitutional provisions.

None of the four provinces has levied income tax on “agricultural income” as defined in the Constitution. The military and civil governments have consistently shown disrespect to the Constitution. This explains why constitutional democracy has failed to work in Pakistan; economic interests of landed aristocracy have primacy over the Constitutional rule whereas it should have been the other way around.

No country can become a democratic society by merely following the system, rather nomenclature, of parliamentary democracy, restricting it to electioneering, unless it demonstrates by action.

In Pakistan, we have witnessed just the opposite behavior. Lawmakers themselves blatantly violate the law but insist that others respect and follow the rule of law for the perpetuation of their economic interests. The beginning of change in Pakistan will be the day when these classes are taxed to give a blow to their ill-gotten money.

The writers, authors of many books and tax advisers, are Visiting Professors at Lahore University

Tags:  , ,

Readers Comments (2)
  1. QAMAR ABBAS says:

    Please tell me that how much tax is due if agricultural land is 10 acr , 12 acr or over 12 acr.
    my land is 16 acar,,,,
    how much tax i have to pay to punjab government.

    please reply me soon

    best regards





Premium WordPress Themes

Commodities Rally Across Board

Food Supplies, Investment Bubble Among Worries; Gold ...

Food Prices to Surge Next Year on Chinese Demand, Oil, Rabobank Forecasts

Farm-commodity prices including corn will extend rallies ...

Agriculture teachers are in high demand

Chuck Miller didn’t let his students get ...

Africa ‘can feed itself in a generation

A new book claims Africa could feed ...

India Likely To Allow More Sugar Exports If Output Over 24.5M Tons

India is likely to allow more sugar ...

The growing problem: Canada slips from agricultural superpower status

Canada is falling behind and farmers blame ...

India expands kissan call centers to help farmers

Commodity Online: India's Kissan Call Centres have ...

Commodities Retreat On Worries Of China Rate Hike

Commodities tumbled across the board, part of ...

The rise of agriculture and Indonesia’s future

Johannes Simbolon, Jakarta Long regarded by many as ...

Japan keen to cut agriculture barriers

Japan's Prime Minister, Naoto Kan, has delivered ...

Women seek to put new face on big agriculture

The image of American agriculture has suffered ...

World’s first robot milker unveiled

THE world's first robotic rotary dairy which ...

USDA estimates to push up global cotton prices

By Seshadri Ramkumar The United States Department of ...

Wall Street bets on commodities trader

[caption id="attachment_825" align="alignleft" width="300" caption="A Gavilon storage ...

Commodities Soar As Surging Demand Meets Dwindling Supplies

A broad array of commodities hit multiyear ...
WordPress Themes