• Home
  • About Us
  • News Letter
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising
  • Strategic Partners
  • Site Map
  • Privacy Policy
Saturday, May 9th
Agriculture Corner
  • AGRI NEWS
    • Global News
    • National News
    • More News
  • CROPS
    • Cotton
    • Maize
    • Rice
    • Sugarcane
    • Wheat
  • HORTICULTURE
    • FRUITS
      • Mango
      • Citrus
      • Apple
    • VEGETABLES
      • Cabbage
      • Caulifower
      • Onion
      • Potato
    • FLOWERS
      • Bulbs
      • Jasmine
      • Rose
  • KNOWLEDGE CENTER
    • mAgricorner
    • Agribusiness
    • Alternative Energy
    • Weather
    • Education
    • Hot Topics
    • ICT4D
    • Jobs & Scholorships
    • Model Farming
    • WareHousing
    • Farm Advisory
  • LIVE STOCK
    • Dairy
    • Poultry
  • Urdu
Agriculture Corner -Empowering farmers with best information through mobile & web tools

Download Free Mobile App

Follow Agriculture Corner

Advertise here

Place your brand here. info[at]agricorner.com

Web Stats February-2015:
Registered Member : 3,400
Sessions: 18,000
Page Views: 25,500

Top Locations :
Pakistan: 32%
USA: 23%
India: 15%

Pakistan Economic Survey

Economic Survey 2013-14

Economic Survey 2012-13

Register With Us / Newsletter

Register as AGRICULTURE Farmer / Businessmen / Expert / Professional / Student & get latest info in your mail box . 3,100 Subscribers as on October, 2014.

Real Time Commodities Quotes


The Commodity Prices Powered by Investing.com

Agriculture Corner Forum

Join Agriculture Corner Yahoo Forum mailing list to receive the daily commodities write up, Daily Commodity closing, Periodic Global Agriculture Reports about Production, Consumption, Trade; Developments in Agriculture Innovation, Mobile Agriculture, and lot more stuff;
Join Agriculture Corner

Agriculture Weather Pakistan

  • Most Commented
  • Most Viewed
  1. Scholarships available students to do MSc agricultural extension program 66 comments
  2. Masters and PhD Scholarship in Agriculture for African Countries, Australia 2012-2013 40 comments
  3. Solar tube-well installation: 'government to give 80 percent subsidy' 33 comments
  4. Initiatives for olive plantation in Pakistan 30 comments
  5. India expands kissan call centers to help farmers 26 comments
  1. Agriculture Growth: Pakistan Economic Survey 2012-13 16044 views
  2. German firm to set up first solar panel plant in Pakistan 10909 views
  3. World Top Ten Wheat Producers 2013 10325 views
  4. Solar tube-well installation: ‘government to give 80 percent subsidy’ 10113 views
  5. Production Status Of Major Vegetables In Pakistan, Their Problems And Suggestions 10103 views

Social Widget

  • RSS Feed RSS FeedSubscribe Now
  •  EmailContact Us
  •  TwitterFollow Us
  •  FacebookAdd Us
 

Archives

Join us on Facebook

You are here: Home » KNOWLEDGE CENTER » Hot Topics »

A Spoonful of Sugar Will Soon Cost More

December 31, 2010 7:21 am 1 comment Views:

Share this Article

  • TwitterTwitter
  • FacebookFacebook
  • DeliciousDelicious
  • DiggDigg
  • StumbleuponStumble
  • RedditReddit

Related Posts

  • Statistics belie PSMA estimates: 3.9-4 million tons of sugar output likely
  • 3.8 million tons of sugar to be produced this year
  • Raw Sugar May Tumble Below 20 Cents - Forecasts Second Surplus

sugar spoon 300x198Environmental lawsuits to obstruct and delay biotech crops will raise food prices in 2011.

By GREGORY CONKO
AND HENRY I. MILLER

Despite many years of success with genetically modified plants, various environmentalists won’t stop trying to obstruct biotech foodstuffs. First they tried to frighten consumers away from so-called “Frankenfoods.” That hasn’t worked, so now they’re challenging the procedures that the government uses to approve genetically engineered crop varieties. Two recent lawsuits, involving alfalfa and sugar beets, illustrate the harm that this nuisance litigation can cause.

Federal agencies are required under the National Environmental Policy Act of 1970 to consider the effects that “major actions”—new regulations, the building of a highway with federal funds, or the approval of new agricultural technology, for instance—may have on the “human environment.” If an agency concludes that the action will not have a significant impact, it will issue a relatively brief environmental assessment explaining the basis for its decision. If significant effects are likely, it must prepare a comprehensive Environmental Impact Statement that details every conceivable effect and requires thousands of bureaucrat-hours to prepare.

Thanks to previous prodding by environmentalists, courts have interpreted “human environment” to include not just tangible ecological harms to humans but also hypothetical impacts that are economic, social, cultural, historic or even aesthetic. Thus, if an agency fails to address some tangential or inconsequential issue, activists can take it to court, alleging that the environmental review was incomplete or its conclusions inadequately documented. That’s what is now happening to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA).

In 2005, the department approved the sale and use of alfalfa and sugar beet seeds that have been genetically modified to be resistant to the herbicide glyphosate, the active ingredient in a product known as Roundup. In each case the approval was based on an environmental assessment. Similar biotech crops have been in use for 17 years with no hint of harm, but in 2006 and 2008 environmental organizations and organic farmers sued in federal court, demanding that the USDA prepare full environmental impact statements. These suits have been hugely disruptive for plant breeders, the seed industry and especially farmers.

Agriculture Department scientists evaluated data from hundreds of government-monitored field trials conducted over almost a decade, along with numerous other studies on the real-world effects of Roundup-resistant crops (marketed as “Roundup Ready”). The genetic trait introduced—resistance to the herbicide glyphosate—is harmless to humans and other animals. Several other Roundup Ready crop varieties such as corn and soybeans are already grown on more than 60 million acres each year in the U.S. alone. Thus the department concluded that an environmental assessment was all that was necessary.

Nevertheless, one federal judge revoked the department’s approval of biotech alfalfa in February 2007, and another revoked the approval of biotech sugar beets this August, until the USDA prepared full-scale environmental impact statements. Earlier this month the agency published its Environmental Impact Statement for alfalfa, and not surprisingly found no environmental harm.

Regulators have a few more hoops to jump through before they can reapprove the alfalfa variety—probably not in time for the seeds to be planted in 2011, however. Fortunately, farmers who planted Roundup Ready alfalfa were permitted to continue growing and then harvest that initial crop, so the overall effect on them will be limited.

But the sugar-beet environmental impact statement could take a couple of years to complete, and growers (whose crop accounts for about half of the refined sugar consumed in the U.S.) are in a dire situation. An estimated 95% of the sugar beets grown in the U.S. are of the Roundup Ready variety.

Because so many growers must now switch back to conventional seeds, there will be a shortfall for planting in 2011, and consumers will soon feel the pinch of sharply rising costs. The wholesale commodity price of sugar shot up 55% between August and November, largely as a result of the court’s decision.

Ironically, seeds that are developed by conventional cross-breeding techniques are essentially exempt from regulation, even though the genetic changes introduced by this traditional practice are often numerous, complex, and poorly characterized. Only genetically engineered varieties, which are more precisely crafted and whose changes are more predictable, are subject to special scrutiny.

This illogical regulatory burden exists only because 25 years ago the Agriculture Department rejected the scientific community’s consensus that no special regulations were needed for genetically engineered plants. Instead, it chose to require a mandatory pre-approval process, thereby spawning the “major actions” that trigger Environmental Impact Statements.

Lawsuits to obstruct demonstrably safe and ecologically beneficial technologies make a mockery of environmental law. The litigation and those responsible for it—not biotech crops—are the real nuisance.

Mr. Conko is a senior fellow at the Competitive Enterprise Institute. Dr. Miller, a physician and fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover institution, was the founding director of the FDA’s Office of Biotechnology.

WSJ

Incoming search terms:

  • sugar spoon
  • spoon of sugar
  • a spoonful of sugar
  • spoon full of sugar

1 Comment

  • TSammons
    January 1, 2011
    8:28 pm

    It’s fascinating when a couple of writers supposedly on top of the academic/business/government pyramid produce an article revealing they are either woefully behind on current science and in-the-field evidence of the matter, or are purposefully misleading their readers for political and financial gain.
    The argument before the public and growers is whether GMO crops are safe for the environment, humans and animals.
    The above article is empty of facts in support of their claims, and full of statements that are outright lies.
    The matter as presented before the public and growers is currently focused on the safety and success of GMO crops. A high school student could have written an article of identical persuasion and simplicity as the one above. I find it surprising the Wall Street Journal, Stanford University, and the Competitive Enterprise Institute would presume the average reader, farmer and consumer is more ignorant than they are and not worthy of reading something that is not so obviously biased and includes current, valid data in support.
    The real basis of the argument before the public and the market will soon shift to whether Glyphosate, the foundation of GMO and commercial agricultural crops is safe for humans, animals, soils, our water supplies, our air and eco system quality and sustainablity.
    Current science in multiple disciplines and field evidence around the world proves that it is not. The real costs to human health, our health care system, our loss of soil fertility, our water contamination and air quality, our resistant weeds, bacteria, fungus and feed animal diseases.. has only begun to be identified and quantified.
    The Precautionary Principle is so yesterday’s defense. 2011 will be a pivotal year and a game changer for Glyphosate and the almost 40 year long marketing myth that it is safe for humans & feed animals, and a globally friendly herbicide. The “suite” of companion products that go along with it will be brought into review along with it. BTW, There is no such thing as “Roundup Ready Micro-nutrients” which is the latest marketing monstrosity to hit the streets. Round-up plus Micro-Nutrients is an oxymoron.
    Of course, when GMO commodities are one of the last main things the country has left to sell and bargain with to China and the rest of the developing nations this will no doubt sway the portrayal of the facts and the media to paint a picture preserving the status quo as long as possible, irregardless of the truth.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.


  • Home
  • About Us
  • News Letter
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising
  • Strategic Partners
  • Site Map
  • Privacy Policy
© Copyright 2015 — Agriculture Corner. All Rights Reserved