The image of American agriculture has suffered a few punches in recent years, but “Big Ag” has a secret weapon it hopes will soften the blows: women.
At the annual convention of American Agri-Women, being held at the Ritz-Carlton Hotel this week, a new project is being unveiled that organizers hope will help boost consumers’ opinions of American farming. The effort, loosely dubbed “Common Ground,” will attempt to put a more feminine, friendly and empathetic face on large-scale agriculture by using women farmers to appeal to suburban and urban grocery shoppers — most of whom are women themselves.
“We’re a unique voice because we’re also moms. We’re the ones getting the food on the table,” said Chris Wilson, president of American Agri-Women and lifelong farmer, who is originally from Illinois. “We make a good connection with consumers.”
The project came together within the past year after the National Corn Growers Association, which is based in Chesterfield, and the United Soybean Board, both major commodity groups, decided large-scale agriculture needed to polish its reputation, which many farmers feel has come under attack.
“Farmers feel misunderstood. With Michael Pollan and ‘Food Inc.,’ large agriculture has become the devil, and local and organic is all good,” said Amy Nuccio, of public relations firm Osborn & Barr, referring to the best-selling author and award-winning documentary, both of which are highly critical of large-scale agriculture. “We were searching for a meaningful way to have an impact on that.”
So the association and the board, with the help of Osborn & Barr, started poring over consumer research to find out who they wanted to reach — and how. They learned that because women were making most of the grocery-buying decisions, they were most concerned about where their food comes from. They also learned that Americans have a positive, even nostalgic impression of farmers, but not of “big farming.”
“We’re not targeting the people who have made their minds up, but those women who are frustrated and feel guilty, like they’re not good moms if they don’t buy organic,” Nuccio explained, adding, “Consumers don’t want a slogan, they don’t want an ad campaign. They want a real relationship, which led us to this strategy of woman-to-woman.”
In coming months, the project will roll out in five states — Iowa, Indiana, Kentucky, South Dakota and Nebraska. Project leaders will train women farmers to be spokespersons and will work to get their message out via social media, partnerships with grocery stores and media outreach efforts.
For starters, Common Ground has tapped a 23-year-old South Dakotan, Laura Nielson, to be its face and messenger.
“I think there’s a lot of misunderstanding,” said Nielson, who spoke at the Agri-Women convention Thursday evening. “… We have to keep getting bigger — A, to survive, B, to keep providing all the food that’s needed. Farms aren’t what they were, and people get scared.”
One of the most stubborn misunderstandings, organizers and farmers say, is that the much-derided corporate farms of America are actually family run and account for more than 95 percent of the country’s farms. (Critics counter that the top 3 to 5 percent of the country’s farms are not family farms and account for a disproportionate amount of production. They also point out that many in that 95 percent earn some of their incomes off the farm, too.)
“Most family farms are incorporated, and they have to be incorporated for legal and tax reasons,” said Rick Tolman, head of the Corn Growers group. “… They may have to be bigger in order to stay in business, but they’re still family farmers.”
And now, Tolman and his fellow organizers hope, these farms will have a fresh public face — one that will not just connect with suburban moms, but will reflect the increase in women on the farm. According to U.S. Department of Agriculture censuses, the number of women who run farms rose nearly 30 percent between 2002 and 2007 and now represent 14 percent of the 2.2 million American farms.
Soon their outreach efforts will be under way in more states, with the goal of reaching urban coastal markets.
“Our ultimate goal is to take these women we’re training to markets where there’s no contact with agriculture,” Nuccio said. “We want them to relate to an urban consumer, who might look at the person and say, that person’s like me and that’s a big producer.”
The project goes beyond concerns over image or the frustrations of the misunderstood American farmer. With sales of organic products and the number of farmers markets on the rise, consumers are showing their increasing preference for organic, local or sustainably produced food. Organics represent just 3.7 percent, or $24.8 billion, of the overall food and beverage sales in this country, but the number has surged from $1 billion two decades ago. This rising number, coupled with direct marketing efforts via farmers markets and community supported agriculture programs, might eventually put a bigger dent in the sale of traditional products.
Even more concerning to large-scale farmers is that consumer pressure will lead to changes on the farm — changes with unintended consequences that urban and suburban consumers may not understand fully. Those changes could come from lawmakers and government.
“What if consumers are driving policy?” Nuccio asked.
Or the changes could come from food manufacturers responding to demand from the marketplace.
“We see some threats on the hori-zon with what we call freedom-to-operate issues,” Tolman said. “… There are lot of food companies putting in sustainability measures because of consumer pressures. These get imposed top-down. What we’d like to see is more dialogue between the farmers and the food companies.”
But until that happens, the suburban mom — that potential policy-driving consumer — is the next point of conversation.
“It’s a marketing, PR move, and obviously these groups are smart,” said Honor Schauland, of the Organic Consumers Association, a group that advocates for small-scale farmers. “Women are friendlier. Everybody’s going to get behind that.”
Copyright 2010 www.STLtoday.com
Tags: American Agri-Women, American agriculture, American farming, National Corn Growers Association, USDA