Agriculture income exempted but inputs taxed: RGST
IT is to some extent true that RGST is not a new tax rather a reformed form of General Sales Tax, which had already been in place for the last 20 years and the government is only trying to reform and extend its scope, but the positive aspect of these reforms still go wasted, as agri income will not come under tax net despite the claim of the government that all sectors, which were previously exempted from the GST, will now be included in the tax network.
The government which is also dominated by the feudal lords is not considering the suggestions of economists, media and public seriously, who suggested to tax agricultural income, real estate sector and the rich. It is unfortunate that agriculture income will be exempted from GST reforms on the plea that that it has become a provincial subject after the passage of the 18th Amendment. On the other hand the GST will be imposed on agriculture products like fertilizers, seeds and machinery, resulting into a more hike in prices of basic food items The feudal class is dominating the govt as well as the opposition, so both groups are not thinking in favour of the general public.
The industry, which was already paying tax, now the RGST main focus is still on this sector. It is fact that Pakistan’s economic instability stems in large part from low government revenue resulting from the elite’s use of tax evasion, loopholes, and exemptions. Fewer than three million of Pakistan’s 175 million citizens pay any income taxes, and Pakistan’s tax-to-GDP ratio is just 9 percent. This figure puts Pakistan in the 155th position out of 179 nations on the Heritage Foundation’s Index of Economic Freedom. Only oil-rich countries that impose few taxes perform worse. Without sufficient revenue, the government will continue to be burdened with an unsustainable debt. There is a need to end tax exemptions for the wealthy and develop broader, long-term economic plans for sustainable growth.
Hence reformations in tax regime is useless until the all sectors including agri income is brought under the tax net. Some exempted industries would experience increase in prices of their products after the imposition of GST reforms. Textile, leather, sports goods, surgical items and carpet are the five industries which are currently enjoying exemption from sales tax on local sales and export of their products. Through GST Reforms, the ratio of Sales Tax will be brought down to a uniformed rate of 15%. Currently, it varies between 17-25% creating confusions and complications.
So, according to official circles, instead of propagated increase the GST Reforms will decrease the ratio of Sales Tax from 2-10%, and Federal Govt will bear loses of billions in its revenue. Small business holders with annual turnover of Rs 5 million or below were exempted in the old GST regime. This threshold has been further increased to Rs 7.5 million.
Government claims that key concepts behind introducing GST reforms are to bring uniformity and start documentation of Pakistan’s taxation system that are essential to bring about much needed macro-economic stability. Through proper documentation, GST reforms will bring into tax net those business holders who were collecting GST from consumers but were not depositing it in govt. revenue. According to the government, tax evaders of all sectors will be brought into the tax net through documented regime of GST Reforms, and the size of tax machinery will be reduced due to automation of the documentation process.
Unlike the current GST, where only the retail level bears the burden of taxation, the GST reforms’ burden is distributed proportionately throughout the production/sales chain, making it an inherently fairer tax. Following are the stakeholders involved in sales of most products: 1. Manufacturer. 2. Marketer. 3. Distributor. 4. Wholesaler. 5. Retailer. 6. Consumer. In GST regime, consumer pays 100% GST (varies between 17-25% of product’s value) when buying from retailer. In GST reforms regime, manufacturer, marketer, distributor, wholesaler, and retailer will also share the burden of consumer By and large, manufacturer collects the GST but not all manufacturers deposit it in government’s kitty. Manufacturers, marketers, distributors, wholesalers and retailers are evading tax in GST regime and they will be netted in proposed GST Reforms mechanism.
Inflation is mainly caused by food and fuel prices as well as excessive borrowing and it will not be wrong to say that inflation may get better after the sales tax rate is brought down to a uniform 15 percent. The proposed GST reforms system relies on two parties reporting the exact same data on the size of their transaction. For instance, the car parts maker reports how much they sold to the car manufacturer, who in turn reports how much they paid the car parts maker. But neither side can collude with the other in tax evasion because what decreases one party’s liability directly increases it for the other. In short, there can be no honor among tax thieves.
It would also be very easy for the government to determine exactly who is cheating on their taxes. Since there are only two parties involved, the one whose liability would be reduced if the other is telling the truth is most likely to be the tax evader.
Official claims that the control over price levels may eventually bring down the State Bank’s benchmark policy rate which currently stands a14 per cent. Introduction of GST reforms, withdrawal of subsidies and energy reforms will lead to less borrowing by the government from banks, leading to a possible cut in interest rate.
GST reforms would slash the size of informal economy and bring undocumented businesses under the tax net. The GST reforms will bring into its fold the businesses which are either evading taxes or showing less than actual taxable income.
This is what the government aims to do by introducing GST Reforms certainly makes life difficult for tax evaders, in addition to distributing the tax burden more fairly while at the same time improving the country’s fiscal balance.
Tax-to-GDP ratio on account of the said sales taxes has stagnated on lowest side although internationally, the standard rate of 17 percent sounds on higher side.
The GST Bill, 2010, will replace the present sales Tax Act, 1990, While the issue of collection and administration of sales tax on services are being separately negotiated with the Provinces in the light of recent NFC award.
Under the new GST law, exemptions have been kept intact in respect of basic food items including wheat, rice, pulses, vegetables, fruits, live animals, meat and poultry etc. Edible oil chargeable to Federal excise duty will remain exempted from GST as before.
Exemptions earlier available for philanthropic, charitable, educational, health or scientific research purposes or under international commitments/agreements including grants/aid will also continue. Moreover, life saving drugs, books and other printed materials including newspapers and periodicals have been kept exempted.
Local consumption of sectors like Textile (including carpet, leather, surgical, and supports goods has however, been subjected to tax). Similarly, defense stores, stationary items, dairy products, pharmaceuticals (other then-life saving), agricultural inputs, agricultural machinery and implements, aviation/navigation equipments including ships and air crafts etc. have also been proposed to be taxed.
GST will be chargeable only on value added component of each stage of the supply chain. Sales Tax on goods and services where so authorized by the provinces shall be mutually adjustable so that double taxation does not occur. Cash flow of businesses shall be facilitated through expeditious centralized (electronic) refund payment system. The proposed GST system will certainly not generate any sudden increase in revenue yield.
It will however, increase the overall Tax to GDP ratio from the present below 10 percent to about 12 percent in the next three to five years. NATION
Incoming search terms:
- Exemption in agriculture
- exemption on agriculture produc
- gst on agricultural products pakistan



