Punjab Govt drops Monsanto Bt cotton idea
Munawar Hasan
LAHORE: Punjab, the largest cotton producing province of the country, has decided to drop the proposal of formally introducing certified imported seed of Bt cotton primarily on financial grounds that outweigh the benefits of biotechnology, officials told The News here on Monday.
Arif Nadeem, secretary agriculture Punjab, said that Punjab had dropped the idea of introducing Bt cotton seed in collaboration with Monsanto. He said negotiations in this connection had ended without yielding any tangible result.
A major reason why policy makers in Punjab have decided to cancel finalising deal with biotech giant Monsanto is the changing cotton scene, official sources say.
The biggest threat to cotton in Punjab has been mutated type of cotton leaf curl virus and there is no remedy available with Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) cotton seed against this menace, the sources add. Top officials of provincial agriculture department say that mealy bug has emerged as a potent threat to cotton plant and genetically modified (GM) seed of cotton provides no solution to it.
Moreover, they say, it is a harsh fact that difference of opinions exists over effectiveness of Bt cotton against various pests. They add that there have been reports of adverse impacts of this technology on other plants and on environment.
One such example has been ailing animals feeding on cotton cake that was prepared with seeds of Bt cotton in parts of Punjab. Officials maintain that the case study of India is also there which negates the claim of increasing yield of cotton mainly due to genetically modified organisms.
High costs of cultivation and low returns after the introduction of Bt cotton in India have trapped Indian growers in a debt trap. Besides, there have been reports of adverse impact on human health such as allergic symptoms as well as toxicity in animals grazing on the Bt cotton fields.
The benefits of GM cotton include tolerance against various types of stresses. However, officials say, stress tolerance of the Bt cotton, such as surviving adverse weather conditions, has been stated to be very low.
Ahmad Ali Aulakh, Punjab minister for agriculture, has been a staunch opponent of finalising a deal with Monsanto for introduction of its Bt cotton seed.
In a recent conversation, he clearly said that he opposed finalising deal with Monsanto as a province like Punjab simply cannot afford such arrangements.
He said that he had also convinced Punjab Chief Minister in this regard. He maintained that GM cotton was no remedy to the problems and it was also too costly for poor farmers.
It may be noted that GM cotton was developed by adding a toxic gene (Bacillus thuringiensis) in seed, causing production of this natural insecticide in its tissues that kills various pests.
Incoming search terms:
- bt cotton



