Agriculture sector opposes granting NDMA/MFN status to India
The Agriculture Task Force (ATF) of Pakistan-India Joint Business Forum (PIJBF) is vehemently opposed to granting Non-Discriminatory Market Access/Most Favoured Nation (NDMA/MFN) to India at this stage.
President, Farmers Associates Pakistan (FAP) and Co-Chair of Agriculture Task force, PIJBF, Tariq Bucha in a letter sent to the federal commerce minister has highlighted that agriculture sector, which is by far the biggest employer in the country, categorically opposes granting NDMA/MFN to India till proper preparations are completed on our side to protect our sectors from enormous Indian subsidies, and get significant market access from India for Pakistani goods, to ensure the level playing field as per the requirement laid down in the cabinet decision of February 29, 2012.
Unnecessary haste with which the government of Pakistan is proceeding to open Wagah border and to more than 137 items before India lowers its agriculture tariffs and removes all kinds of Non-Tariff Barriers (NTBs) and Sanitary and Phyto Sanitary (SPS) barriers which are undermining our negotiating leverage and position. “For Agriculture produce and products, Wagah route cannot be opened any further, until a separate bilateral agri-trade agreement is negotiated involving stakeholders including FAP, and is finalised and signed, based on an impartial and independent study for that purpose,” he said.
Moreover, he said, SAFTA does not apply fully to the complexities involved under the WTO regime with respect to agriculture. It is a 15-page agreement with incomplete annexes, and requires significant and severe redefining, restructuring and amendments with detailed stakeholder input and approval, in case it contemplates agri trade between the countries because of enormous current and future subsidies given to agriculture in India that are a hallmark of unfair trade.
Nowhere does the SAFTA agreement require Pakistan to phase out its sensitive list in five years. “Pakistan’s agriculture sector vehemently opposes any further phasing out of agricultural items from the sensitive list. We have read the SAFTA Agreement carefully, and know that there is no such categorical requirement. Any reductions made on the sensitive list are discretionary, and even though a review of the list is required every four years, a ‘review’ does not require a reduction in it,” he stated.
Within the ASEAN regime, which is a far more robust FTA than SAFTA, for example, there are items that remain permanently on a “highly sensitive list”, he said, adding that any representatives of the Government of Pakistan who agrees to unnecessary reductions of the sensitive list must know that they would be doing so without any legal requirement, and would be violating the principle of keeping a level playing field that was set down in the aforementioned cabinet decision, in the wake of the enormous subsidies given by the Indian government.
He suggested that to effectively counter the enormous subsidies on agriculture before opening Wagha and granting NDMA/MFN to India, the Government of Pakistan must first put in place tariff rate quotas per crop that equal the subsidy given to each crop on the Indian side, to ensure a level playing field. “The above steps must be verified by FAP, representing the agri-sector. Once that is done, we could move forward on negotiating a separate agri-trade agreement for bilateral trade with India,” he added.
It has been pointed out in the letter that granting NDMA means that Wagah should still be closed to all Indian goods, because no other country’s goods comes through Wahga. “Therefore, if all goods are restricted from Wagah, that would comply with Non-Discriminatory Market Access. By granting Wagah access to more than 137 Indian goods would amount to granting India even more favourable terms than required by a grant of NDMA/MFN. Granting Wagah access to more than the existing agriculture items will significantly weaken Pakistan’s economy, and already beleaguered agriculture sector,” he said.
Tariq asserted that Congress Party is likely to lose in the upcoming elections in India therefore the agriculture sector strongly opposes granting NDMA/MFN to India particularly when the new Indian government is only few months away and could renege on any concessions that are given to Pakistan by the outgoing Congress government. ‘At this juncture, National Tariff Commission (NTC) does not yet have the capacity or provisions to effectively counter unfair trade practices such as the anticipated dumping and heavy subsidisation of agricultural goods by the Indian side,’ he said.
Before giving any further trade concessions to the Indian side, he said the Ministry of Commerce must demonstrate that the NTC has the ability, capacity and the powers to effectively protect Pakistan’s agriculture from the anticipated onslaught of unfair Indian trade practices of dumping and heavy subsidization. “Since 2011, the Ministry of Commerce has acknowledged that the NTC lacks such capacity, and yet the NTC has not visibly improved. The Ministry of Commerce therefore cannot in good conscience open Wagah or to more than 137 items before it could build a robust NTC’.
Concluding Tariq said, although the agriculture sector is not averse to trade with India in a structured, phased and effectively negotiated agreement, we feel that the government of Pakistan has thus far failed to improve the capacity of its institutions or put in provisions to afford needed protection to its domestic sectors, to help survive the anticipated onslaught of Indian agricultural produce and products. ‘Thus, until such time that the government of Pakistan demonstrates that it is serious about safeguarding Pakistan’s domestic agriculture from unfair competition, we will oppose any move for granting NDMA/MFN and further opening of Wagah’.
Business Recorder
Related articles
Incoming search terms:
- ndmamfN



