Pakistan and India urged to resolve trade issues through talks
Issues of market access to Pakistani agriculture products need to be addressed in the bilateral trade negotiations between India and Pakistan instead of under the Safta agreement. Pakistani agriculture products were not compatible with Indian agri products because India gave huge subsidy to its farmers on electricity and pesticide while Pakistani farmers are facing host of issues.
This was crux of findings made in a report prepared by Development Policy Research Centre (DPRC) of the Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS). Briefing the media, DPRC team comprising Syed Turab Hussain, Abid Hussain Imam, Usman Khan shared that issues of trade in agriculture, pharmaceutical and automobile sectors with India should be resolved through bilateral trade instead of Safta treaty.
In automobile sector, they said, Pakistan and India should initiate joint ventures. They also said that Pakistan should set criteria for trade in pharmaceutical sector with India because Indian medicines are low cost and like Bangladesh, Pakistan should evolve criteria for the import of Indian medicines.
Talking about political economy of subsidy provision in India, they said, “It is highly unlikely that India would reduce the subsidy in near future. Therefore, in short term, what Pakistan needs to negotiate for is Indian reduction in both its applied MFN tariffs on agriculture goods and the specific agriculture-related NTBs that hinder Pakistan’s potential exports.
Opening of the Indian market to Pakistan would go a long way in pacifying the agriculture lobby.” Over the medium to long run, there is considerable opportunity of cross-border investments in agriculture and processed food, given the fact that there have been significant efforts to liberalise the investment regime in both the countries.
Likewise, there is tremendous scope in trade and joint ventures, investments in inputs such as seeds and agricultural appliances. Moreover, with increased water scarcity and changing weather patterns, there is a dire need for the two countries to resolve their outstanding water issues and treat water as a common resource.
Finally both India and Pakistan should institutionalise research linkages to facilitate transfers of technology for more sustainable agricultural practices in the region. Despite the fact that Pakistan has not extended MFN and maintains a negative list with India, both the overall and agricultural trade balance is still heavily tilted in India’s favour.
1- The major agriculture imports from India have been cotton, refined sugar and more recently, fresh vegetables.
2- On the other hand, the main agricultural export of Pakistan to India over the past two years has been dried dates ($47.2 million in 2011).
Analysis of relative competitiveness in agricultural products indicates that Pakistan has considerable potential in exporting to India. Various studies, which have carried out Revealed Comparative Advantage (RCA) calculations show that Pakistan is competitive in citrus fruit, mangoes, apricots, peaches, olives, fish and fish products.
These products have the potential to attract significant demand in Indian markets. Furthermore, India with its huge population (of more than 300 million people belonging to the middle-class) offers a lot of opportunities for export of value-added agricultural processed fresh and preserved food, dairy products, juices and vegetable food supplements. Also, niche export market opportunities exist for vegetarian, Halal, kosher and organic products.
In particular, there was a detailed discussion held around the research on the impact of open trade with India, on the agriculture sector. This discussion was particularly relevant as it was based on the first of the four articles to be published in the newspapers over the next couple of months.
Dr Turab Hussain explained in some detail, how the major hindrance to open trade with India, as far as the agriculture sector was concerned, was the high degree restrictions placed by India that hamper exports for Pakistan entering India. Therefore, he explained how policy dialogue at bilateral level should focus more on negotiating relaxations on this front.
In addition, the briefing also focused on other key findings of this research project, which will also be incorporated in to the four part article series. These articles will include findings relating to the impact on domestic auto and pharmaceutical industries of opening trade with India.
Another article will be wholly dedicated to exploring alternate dispute resolution mechanisms, which would help facilitate open trade between the two countries. The final article of the four part series, will lay out for the reader in detail, the overall economic impact of enforcing Safta and granting MFN status to India, on domestic macroeconomic indicators including the trade balance, GDP, employment and other such variables.
Business Recorder
Related articles



