Woes of fertilizer industry: increased prices could translate into Rs 70 billion loss to GDP: FMPAC ED
Highlighting the woes of fertilizer industry, Fertilizer Manufacturers Pakistan Advisory Council (FMPAC) expressed the fear that in case urea prices increased by Rs 150 to 200 per bag, urea application would decline by eight to 10 percent resulting in approximately eight percent drop in acreage which would translate into a loss of Rs 70 billion to country’s GDP.
FMPAC’s, Executive Director, Shahab Khawaja in an interactive session with media people at a hotel here on Tuesday, said urea manufacturing plants, despite unprecedented gas curtailment in the last five years, passed on Rs 374 billion benefits to the farmers by keeping local urea prices significantly below international levels.
There is a misconception that fertilizer manufacturers enjoy raw material subsidy from the government in the form of reduced feed gas prices. This subsidy is not for the manufacturers, but is in fact passed on to the farmer via reduced prices. Therefore, he said not only was the fertilizer industry passing on feed gas subsidy to the farmer, but was also passing on a much larger benefit voluntarily in addition to paying taxes to government.
He said in 2013 average difference between domestic and import price was Rs 846 per bag out of which government provided subsidy through concessionary feed gas of Rs 66 per bag (net of taxes) and remaining Rs 780 per bag was passed on to farmers by the fertilizer sector resulting in billions of rupees of benefits to farmers due to local urea production.
He said that this happened despite the fact that there was no legal or moral obligation to maintain such differential between locally produced urea and imported urea. Local urea price has increased by Rs 1,126 per bag in the last five years with 89 percent of the increase due to government taxes and normal inflation. Only 11 percent of the price increase is due to gas curtailment as government did not honour its gas supply contracts with the fertilizer manufacturers despite the fact that industry has recently invested $2.3 billion in the country based on the government approved policy designed to encourage investment in the sector.
He further said fertilizer sector produced five million tons of urea in 2008 against a capacity of 5.1 million tons, in 2009 five million tons against 5.1 million tons capacity, in 2010 5.2 million tons against 5.6 million tons capacity, in 2011 4.9 million tons against production capacity of 6.9 million tons, in 2012 4.2 million tons against production capacity of 6.9 million tons and finally in 2013 the production remained at 4.8 million tons which was 2.1 million less than the total production capacity of 6.9 million tons.
He said that declining urea production in last four years from 2010 to 2013 had resulted in billions of dollar loss to national exchequer in terms of urea import and subsequent subsidy to keep the prices at par with locally produced urea. The years 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2013 have been the worst years for fertilizer sector as instead of providing gas to local fertilizer plants to produce economical urea domestically, the government preferred to import urea by spending a hefty amount of approximately two billion dollars precious foreign exchange.
In 2013 alone government had to face a loss of 335 million dollars on importing 968,000 tons of urea and it also provided subsidy worth Rs 17 billion on imported urea, he said. Shahab Khawaja said the government must realise that agriculture contributed around 21 percent to the GDP of Pakistan and it also provided raw materials to all the major industries of Pakistan including, textiles and sugar.
For the economy of Pakistan to prosper, it is important for agricultural yields to go up which is only possible through the application of fertilisers in the right quantity at the right time. The decline in urea production poses a severe threat to the crops yield; resultantly the country might miss its agriculture and export targets and also aggravate inflation in the country which is already higher than the regional peers.
Fertilizer sector paid Rs 73 billion in taxes in last five years despite lower production and if government wanted it could even earn foreign exchange by exporting the surplus urea production by ensuring gas to fertilizer plants, he said. He said if local urea industry was closed down, it would cost approximately 2.3 billion dollars to import required quantities of urea and an additional subsidy of Rs 96 billion to maintain current domestic local prices.
He said if urea prices moved to international parity, farmer’s community would possibly bear the burden of approximately Rs 100 billion on collective annual income and if that cost increase was passed on to end consumer it would result in rampant food inflation and food insecurity in the country.
Business Recorder




