Strategy to be formed for boosting kinnow exports
The government must discourage private sector from exporting country’s prized fruits, i.e. Kinnow and mangoes to commissioned markets where the return is minimal.
Ahmad Jawad, Chief Executive Officer, Harvest Trading (HT) told that government must concentrate on countries like Australia, Japan, Turkmenistan, Sudan and Iraq who offer a huge market for the export of these fruits.
These countries have big potential but have remained un- exploited due to the negligence and weak policies of the public sector, he said.
He said government must look towards encouraging exports of fresh produce, particularly Kinnow and mangoes, urging at the same time Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) to wake-up and play an active role in discovering new markets and increasing country’s exports of fresh fruits and vegetables which were in great demand in the non-traditional markets. There is urgent need to exploit these markets.
Jawad said that currently 50% of Kinnow and mangoes in exports quota are being exported to UAE and Saudi Arabia which are commissioned markets and not a big attraction by any standards for exporters of fresh fruits and vegetables.
Every year exporters suffer a huge loss for want of proper marketing strategy to access other profitable markets, with the result that Pakistani exporters do not get better returns, he regretted.
He said due attention be paid to research and development (R & D) in which achieving targets would be difficult without it. As the kinnow export season starts, farmers are hoping for the best. They have some valid reasons for this optimism. However, the fruit has experienced a bumpy start of season with a variety of challenges in the way of making this goal into a reality . If things remain on track Kinnow export target had achieved 0.3 million tons this year easily and expected to generate more than $100 million in export earnings which is healthy sign.
However, the kinnow faced tough price competition with the variety from China and has failed to win the Indonesian market. The fate of the exports partially lies in the hands of reasons that cannot be predicted at the moment.
Iran, which imports 50,000 to 60,000 tons of the local kinno is a market that depends on the timing of the reduction in duty by their government: Last year, Iranian government reduced the duty from 90 to 4 percent in the first week of January; a delay this year will cause the local prices to escalate, not to forget the dent it will cause to the exports; Jawad added.
The exporters have been very disappointed by the support or rather lack of it, by the local custom authorities.
Perishable items which used to get cleared quickly in the past have to now go through the whole process, causing damage to the packaged fruit with varying temperatures and careless handling.
According to details in one 40 FCL container, 50 percent of the fruit was damaged when it reached Dubai a few days ago, because of the new checking techniques by the customs.
CEO Harvest Tradings said the planners need to realise that there are certain areas where the private sector cannot help exports grow. Take an example of the banking sector linkage. For the last few years, as the Russian and Iranian markets opened up for Pakistani kinnow, exporters are having payment problems from both these markets.
If it is not solved on priority basis, Pakistan can easily loose both markets that now consume more than half of kinnow exports. Only the government can create efficient linkage, which helps exports. It also needs a dedicated agency that documents, preferably pre-empts, such problems and keep the export process smooth. As Pakistan’s kinnow season was delayed by 14 days and now it starts.
Jawad quoted from Australia Center for International Agriculture Research which mentioned in its latest news bulletin that Pakistan contributed more than 4 per cent of the world mango production but received the lowest average price per kg of any major exporting country in the world due to poor quality.
Our agricultural production is more than our domestic consumption but we are still not able to make our presence felt in the international market. One of the reasons behind this is a unique but unsophisticated network of up to six or seven intermediaries between the primary source (producer and growers) and the end user. Because of the presence of so many layers and the lack of adequate marketing infrastructure facilities, 30 to 40% of the perishable produce spoils before reaching the ultimate consumer.
He further urged the government to take all corrective measures to make Commercial Counselors at Pakistan’s foreign missions visibly contribute in promotion of the country’s trade and investment.
The CEO emphasized that starting with Pakistan’s image building the Trade or Counselors should work as Marketing Managers fully knowing about the market demand there and about the quality of products and selling tactics by Pakistan’s competitors.
They should be very much in touch with the business communities there, exchange business data and information , provide businessmen at both ends with proper consultation meant to increase bilateral trade and investment , help resolve trade disputes between entrepreneurs of Pakistan and any other country.
Comments of a Professional: Mr Rupart Knowles In the summer of 2010, I was part of a mission looking at mangoes and kinnow in Punjab. It was quite clear to us that the only problem with Pakistan horticulture and exports was the government. Until the government gets itsgreasy hands out of the till and stops interfering, Pakistan is going nowhere. I read a history of Mitchell Farms, one of the oldest kinnow institutions: even under British rule, they succeded in spite of government!
There are orchards and packhouses that are supposedly GlobalGAP certified, but they only pay lip-service to it. If a proper inspection were carried out, they would surely fail.
Ahmad Jawad’s points have been reiterated by many. Most Pakistani fruit is sold abroad through small emigre Pakistani wholesalers on a commission basis. Pakistani mangoes and Kinnow are second to none in flavour (in spite of the pips), but they will never break into advanced markets until they team up with reputable importers supplying the multiples and learn GAP, SPS and other certification requirements in the private sector. Government’s role is to facilitate: to foster accredited laboratories, to train extensionists with real qualifications, to smooth export certification and so on.
Good luck to the small farmers, but I fear they face a long uphill struggle.
Pakistan Observer



