Smaller provinces cry for agri credit
Overall agricultural credit disbursement by banks has increased substantially over four years, but the share of smaller provinces has been meagre. Farmers in Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan continue to rely heavily on costly borrowings from informal sources.
In FY13, when banks disbursed Rs336 billion agricultural loans, more than 86 per cent of it went to Punjab. All other provinces and Azad Jammu and Kashmir got less than 14 per cent. And this was no deviation from the past trend.
Punjab being the most populous province is home to more farm workers than in all the three provinces combined. Besides, the province produces the bulk of all major crops in the country i.e. cotton, wheat, rice, sugarcane and maize. So, there is always a bigger demand for agricultural credit there. But demand alone does not explain this lop-sidedness. “Banks seem to be ignoring credit demand from smaller provinces,” says a legislator-cum-landlord from rural Sindh. Small growers maintain that unlike in Punjab, extra large land holdings in smaller provinces are still common and big farmers of these provinces get the bulk of agricultural credit using their clout. Banks, therefore, don’t bother to lend to most of eligible growers, as they do in Punjab.
But what dilutes this argument is that per-party credit off-take in Punjab and Sindh does not show any big difference. “In FY13, average per-party borrowing in Punjab was Rs181,400 whereas in Sindh it was Rs187,874,” points out head of agricultural credit department of a large local bank. Whether the smaller provinces are getting adequate share in farm loans can also be found out by relating it to their contribution to country’s agricultural output. On this count too, things are far from ideal. Sindh contributes about one-fourth to the country’s total value-added agriculture. “But our share in credit has remained range-bound between 10-12 per cent for last 10 years,” laments a senior official of Sindh’s agriculture department.
He recalls that up to 2000-01 Sindh’s share in farm credit was about 21 per cent, closer to its contribution in agricultural GDP. But, later on, limited availability of farmers’ pass-books and scant cooperation of the revenue department in their verification decelerated credit distribution.
Increased cooperation of Sindh Revenue Department in verification of pass-books and computerisation of land records are must to help banks enhance agricultural lending. “Issuance of bogus pass-books that crossed all limits in the last five years also has to be checked,” insists a local banker.
All five major banks — National, Habib, MCB, United and Allied — often exceed their indicative targets for agricultural lending, but several other domestic private banks lag behind. “This failure is also affecting the off-take of farm credit in Sindh, KPK and Balochistan. The same is true for Zarai Taraqiati (Agricultural Development) Bank.”
Botch-ups in recovery also affect fresh loaning to farmers. Bankers point out that in case of Balochistan, for example, very low rate of recovery forces them to make fewer loans. Farmers say militancy and drought-like conditions in many districts hamper normal activity there, causing a slump in demand for credit, particularly for farming development. From bankers’ point of view, militancy is a greater hurdle because it affects branch-level operations in all spheres of banking activity.
In the KP, the situation is a bit better chiefly because most of loaning there is directed at key crops of the area like wheat, sugarcane, sugar beet and tobacco. Bankers say over the years, they have established good working relationship with the growers of these crops. Moreover, farm inputs supply system in KP and Punjab is better organised than in Sindh and Balochistan.
Banks agri loans meet only one-third of the total demand and farmers have to fill in the gap with costlier informal borrowings. But very low lending to a particular area means farmers’ reliance on informal borrowings may increase to unmanageable proportions in view of rising cost of farm inputs.
Central bankers say involvement of microfinance banks in agricultural lending programme from FY12 is helping in financial inclusion of small growers which, by extension, would also help in boosting the share of smaller provinces in agricultural lending. Now the inclusion of Islamic banks in the same programme from this fiscal year should also help in furthering this agenda.
Data of last two years indicate that microfinance banks have been boosting agricultural credit. But more evidence is needed to establish if they had any significant impact on the share of credit smaller provinces.
Dawn



