‘Raw milk used to produce milk, cream, ghee and butter’
LAHORE: Reacting to the recent reports regarding the concerns raised by the dairy farmers, the Pakistan Dairy Association (PDA) has said milk, cream, ghee, butter and other dairy products are solely produced from raw milk and no milk powder is consumed in its processing.
PDA Secretary General Farrukh Shahzad Mughal said that claims by Kissan Ittehad that imported milk powder was used, as a replacement of milk in these products was a deliberate attempt to hurt the dairy industry and misguide the lawmakers. He said, “Processing companies have always been supportive of the dairy farmers and their families and these farmers were very happy to work with us.
The processing companies not only offer good price for the milk but also facilitates the farmers by providing guidance over animal health, suggested feeds, establishing village milk centres in rural areas, providing financial support to increase shed size, free of cost trainings to improve yield of animal and guidance over proper milking methods.”
He said processing companies have a large network of sub-centres located overall the milk rich areas of the country to ensure that small dairy farmers get easy access to milk centres. “These dairy companies pay good rates to these small dairy farmers directly.
On the contrary, in the areas where dairy companies are not present, one where milk contractors have a strong presence, the small dairy farmers are exploited and these contractors enjoy high rates on the expense of these small farmers. Further, processing companies do not discriminate between suppliers and offer rates that are pre-announced in the shed,” he added.
“The imported skimmed milk powder is consumed in production of tea whiteners. Tea is the basic drink in our region and these tea whiteners are used to make that, he said. These tea whiteners cater to the needs of the poor segment of the society i.e. socio economic class C and D who are unable to afford expensive full cream milk for their tea making.
Tea whitener being a formulated product necessitates the use of skimmed milk powders that offer better shelf life, better taste profile and product stability as compared to the locally available raw milk. Further, imported milk powders are used in infant formula solely due to the fact that the locally procured raw milk cannot give the desired quality that can be fed to the infants.”
Considering the buying power of its customers despite inflationary pressures dairy companies have decreased the per litre price of tea whiteners by approximate Rs 16 in the last three years. This fact indicates that the processing companies work towards the interest of masses.
Any increase in the customs duty on imported milk powders as demanded by KI would result in food inflation, as tea whiteners the usage of milk powder and despite high demand will continue to be imported. Contrary to what KI may like to portray, the dairy industry would not switch to using raw milk for the production of tea whiteners as the recipe does not allow the same and any assumption of KI for charging high milk prices through this tactic will not succeed.
He said more than 600,000 million farmers are associated with the processing companies. This suggestion to increase the duty will go against the interest of these farmers who will then be exploited by the milk contractors. The milk price in Pakistan is 35% higher as compared to India in equal dollar terms.
Prices have increased by greater than 10% in Pakistan since 2014 that is much higher than the inflation rate. The current prices of raw milk are reasonable for even moderately efficient farmers and can provide reasonable gains to them. Processing companies shall not be held responsible, for the lower profits due to inefficiencies of the dairy farmers, by increasing the milk price through increase in duty of milk powder.
Pakistan is a member of the WTO and it has committed that it will not levy excessive tariffs as it kills competition and destroys free trade. The revised duty of 20% in this budget (which was welcomed by PDA) is still a substantial duty on imported milk powders.
Increasing this duty would not bring any benefit to the dairy farmers as milk powder will still be imported trying to cover the inefficiencies by increasing the selling price is not a rational method of generating profits. Dairy farming sector of Pakistan needs to improve its yield and efficiency to control the costs.
As far as the comparison with the Turkish model in concerned, it is pertinent to mention that the government of Turkey implemented Minimum Pasteurisation Act and restricted sale of unpasteurised milk, hefty subsidies were granted to make turkey net exporter of milk and then afterwards the duty rates were increased.
Proposing to increase the duty in Pakistan at first, a country that is net importer of milk is basically holding the thread from the opposite end. We should first make Pakistan self-sustained or a net exporter of milk and implement the Minimum Pasteurisation Act after which duties can be increased, otherwise this will surely cause food inflation in the country.
The members of the KI should note that the raw milk available in the market is adulterated and fabricated regardless of high prices offered by the processing companies. This is the reason why processing companies reject tons of raw milk due to quality issues.
Processing industries have been bearing huge testing costs to ensure that good quality milk is procured and best quality products are supplied to the general public. They should work on the provision of quality milk instead of misguiding the government.
He said the prevailing milk price in Pakistan is 35% higher in equal dollar terms as compared to India. Any increase in customs duty will force the processing companies to increase the price of the products that in turn will result in lower demand and would restrict the overall production volume of the processing companies.
Reduction in output will lead to less input required and the raw milk procurement for all other products would decline accordingly resulting in loss of livelihood for the dairy farmers. In true spirit of the above stated facts the government would be ill-advised to agree upon the baseless demands made by KI that are against the best interest of the dairy farmers and the dairy industry.
News source: Daily Times
Image source: joelminden.com




