Prices up in major markets after short respite
With harvesting in full swing, wheat prices should have fallen by the end of April. Instead, the commodity became costlier in two leading urban markets, thanks to structural flaws in supply chain management.
On arrival of the new crop wholesale price had crashed to Rs2,900-Rs3,000 per 100 kg by the end of March from Rs3,400-Rs3,500 per 100kg in February.
“For the last few days in March and into the first week of April, we were getting supplies even at Rs2,850 per 100kg (just equal to the official support price),” recalls a big flour miller from Karachi. But the trend took a U-turn and average price rose to Rs3,100 per 100kg by the end of last month.
Now that the Sindh government has restricted inter-provincial movement of the commodity from May 1 the situation will depend upon “how efficiently the provincial caretaker government curbs hoarding,” Sindh-Balochistan chairman of Pakistan Flour Mills Association
Ansar Javed said at a recent press conference.
Wheat prices are rising in Sindh because of large-scale hoarding, increased export-led buying and also because local millers were not getting supplies from Punjab. And in Punjab the prices are up, partly because official procurement is going on, and partly because wheat harvesting and thrashing in many districts has still not picked up pace.
“Though an official ban on inter-district movement has just been imposed, unofficially provincial governments of Punjab and Sindh were discouraging movements of wheat right from the arrival of the new crop. This affected supplies in Karachi as shortfall due to ongoing hoarding could not be compensated with buying from Punjab. Besides, in Punjab too there was not much wheat available,” says ex-chairman of Pakistan Flour Mills Association Akhtar Hussain.
Flour millers in rural Sindh say that prices of wheat are rising there as well, (despite the fact that unlike in Karachi wheat is grown in their areas), because farmers and traders follow Karachi’s rates. “When there are no supplies from Punjab, prices throughout Sindh move up, also due to hoarding of locally produced wheat,” a Hyderabad-based miller informed Dawn over the telephone.
He said that traders in rural Sindh were fleecing both farmers and millers — by forcing the former to sell wheat below the support price of Rs2,850 per 100kg telling them that official procurement would be delayed and by compelling the latter to pay higher prices because of low level supplies. This is also affecting official procurement of wheat by Sindh Food Department. Javed says that by April 30 the department had hardly bought 300,000 tonnes from the new wheat crop against the target of 1.3 million tonnes. He feared that if hoarding and
large-scale buying by exporters continued the food department would miss the procurement target and that would create problems later during the year when the department would start supplying subsidised wheat to the millers. Normally such supply starts in August and continues through February next year — when open market stocks deplete.
In March wheat exports surged to 6,817 tonnes against just 54 tonnes in February when harvesting of the new crop had not started.
Traders at Jodia Bazar, Karachi, say that export-led buying was aggressive in April as well while admitting that this was one of the reasons for the price hike.
Wheat output this year is estimated around 26.207 million tonnes, if the Suparco projection is to be believed. But officials of ministry of national food security and research term it optimistic. They say that field reports suggest a total production of no more than 25 million tonnes at best.
Wheat prices are also moving up because a switch-over from gold to commodities in international investors’ preference and a spike in international wheat prices have also affected dynamics of the local market. In world markets, the average price of hard red winter wheat surged from about $304 per tonne by the end of March to about $322 per tonne by the end of April.
“But now, with reports coming in from India — the second largest grower country of wheat — that it may remove a cap on the lowest export price, we may actually see some decline in wheat prices,” says a Jodia Bazar-based trader. “Besides, weather conditions in the US, that had earlier caused a concern for global wheat output, are fast improving and US wheat supplies are also set to improve. That too would affect the market in terms of softening of prices.” Traders also say that the recent increase in wheat exports would not impact unfavourably on prices after sometime when production in Punjab would accelerate and output estimates that look a bit optimistic right now would become a reality.
On top of all this is an optimistic wheat output forecast by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the UN which says that global wheat output this year would be 690 million tonnes, up 4.3 per cent from 2012, and second largest on record after the 700 million tonnes seen in 2011.
“So, I believe the spike in local wheat prices is more because of peculiar domestic factors and will prove short-lived,” says another leading trader of food commodities.
RICE: Traders say with an increase in exports of various varieties of Basmati, their local prices also increased marginally. Growers say whereas this year’s overall paddy crop is fairly larger than that of the last year, Basmati output is estimated to see only a nominal increase.
That is why Basmati prices had started rising months ago and after remaining somewhat stable during the month of March, are on the rise again.
They say one of the reasons for increase in prices of Basmati is its aggressive corporate buying for both domestic sales and exports in five kg packing. One example for higher industrial intake of rice is that Engro Food’s rice business revenues surged to Rs1.2 billion in the first quarter of this year from a little over Rs160 million in the same period of the last year, company’s recently released financial results show.





