No change in wheat output target and support price
The Federal Committee on Agriculture, which met last week for the first time after the passage of 18th Amendment, has fixed national wheat production target at 25 million tonnes.
Out of this, Punjab is supposed to produce 19 million tonnes, Sindh 3.8 million, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa 1.35 million and Balochistan 0.85 million tonnes.
The FCA, which was also expected to recommend, if not announce, the support price as well, ignored that part.
This is despite the fact that the cost of production has increased by 10 to 15 per cent in the last one year, if farmers’ claims are to be believed.
Secondly, the increased price is generally taken as an incentive to increase productivity. The committee neither increased the target, as compared to last year, nor touched the support price despite compelling reasons to revise both upwards. After all, population is increasing every year and so is the cost of production.
In fact, the committee did not dwell on the price for two reasons: effect on productivity and impact on inflation. It is already mid-November — the most propitious time for sowing — and farmers have made up their mind and soil for the purpose.
So, as the official thinking goes, with some measure of justification, price increase at this stage could not have brought more acres under wheat. The new price, even if hiked, would have entailed a marginal increase anyway, remaining almost irrelevant to wheat economics.
The increase, however, could have certainly had disproportionate impact on the inflationary trends.
It could have further increased flour price by mounting speculative pressure on price that has already gotten close to alarming proportion for a majority of population, worked as incentive for hoarding and made flour market even more volatile. Thus, the support price issue was ignored and seems to be settled for the season.
But in the absence of price incentive, how is the country going to achieve the 25-million-tonnes target? The first glimpse of the enormity of target came when Punjab refused to take 19.5 million tonnes as its target, insisting on 19 million tonnes, arguing that it has never crossed the figure even in the best of circumstances. This year, it cannot be expected to perform a miracle.
Punjab is crucial in national scheme of agriculture things. If it flunks, others cannot make up for the loss as is evident from the apportionment of target. Punjab has been struggling for the last many years between 18 to 18.5 million tonnes.
Though productivity has increased from 26.43 maunds per acre (2007) to 30.90 maunds (2012), it is progressively losing area to competing crops.
During the same period, its wheat acreage has come down from 16.8 million acres to 16.1 million acres. The loss of these 700,000 acres brings overall production figures down and Punjab has no way to bring them back unless it either increases price exceptionally or competing crops lose their financial attraction.
Historically, wheat acreage in Punjab ranged from 15 million to 16 million acres. In 2008, two to three million acres were added when price was increased by 46 per cent by the then PPP government.
Since then, wheat economics for farmers is on the slide, and it is reflected in the ever-decreasing acreage. This is why Punjab insists on lower production targets, taking the national figures down.
Apart from the provincial reservations, a national strategy to achieve such a target is also missing. This is why the federal government has been fixing target of 25 million tonnes for the last many years, missing it with big margin and religiously repeating it the next year.
Each passing year takes it further away from the target because more and more uncertainties are added to the crop cycle.
Even factors like fertiliser, which should normally be considered a constant in national strategy, have become variable, robbing the productivity estimates of their certainty.
This year, no one knows how much urea and DAP would be available to farmers, when they would be available and at what price.
In the last few years, market situation and official policies have only made crop uncertain. Both are ruled by ad hoc preferences that change mid-stream, playing havoc with farmers.
The entire market is ruled by the cartels that only ensure minimum return to farmers and maximise it for the middleman.
The government procurement policies are determined by the political situation around the harvesting time and the research and development policies are inadequate.
Agriculture was handed over to provinces, along with extra money under the National Finance Commission, hoping that they would invest more in it.
Instead, the sector is now suffering double jeopardy: federal money is not available and provinces are still unable to bridge the gap.
Dawn



