Malpractice, negligence influence irrigation water administration in Sindh: conference told
Water experts, agriculturists, academia, media persons, civil society representatives and farmers have expressed that malpractice and negligence influence the governance of water in Sindh, causing a major crisis in agriculture output. Government officials, however, have dispelled this realisation while admitting there is ample room for improving water governance.
While addressing a provincial water conference here on Wednesday, the experts emphasised upon the provincial government to come up with an inclusive provincial water policy so as to cope with upcoming water-related challenges. The conference was organised by Indus Consortium in collaboration with Oxfam Pakistan and Laar Humanitarian and Development Programme (LHDP) for presenting policy draft on Sindh irrigation water prepared through consultations with local communities, water experts, line departments and broader civil society.
The event was attended by a large number of academicians, water experts, government officials, media persons, representatives of civil society and farmers’ communities from Sindh and Punjab.
The conference enabled all stakeholders to give their inputs to design a set of recommendations for policymakers. The Policy brief presented in the conference recommends to the provincial government of Sindh that the public task of policy framing should be accomplished through the integration of actors’ representation approach and adoption of actual policy frames. An actor representation approach emphasises the changing positions and distribution of actors in policy deliberation and decision-making. The second approach aims at the changing distribution of frames that actors attach to a policy and practice.
Syed Zaheer Hyder Shah, provincial irrigation secretary, said that as far as the problems of tail-end farmer communities are concerned, which have been mentioned in many a speeches today, I assure you all that Sindh irrigation department is working day-in day-out to solve these problems under the visionary guidance of Chief Minister Sindh, Syed Qaim Ali Shah.
“We are fully aware that water challenges being faced by Sindh province are not ordinary. But our efforts to meet these challenges are equally concerted. We are relentlessly working to mitigate the water-related issues of tail-end farmer communities across Sindh,” irrigation secretary added. He informed the audience that during last financial year, as many as 219 different development schemes were completed by Irrigation department at a total cost of Rs 57.6 billion.
World renowned water expert Dr Shahid Ahmad said that Indus basin irrigation system is the largest irrigation system of the world currently having complex problems. “Reforms in departments of irrigation are only possible when there is ownership. The Institutional reforms promulgated with the enforcement of the provincial acts of Irrigation and Drainage Authorities could not be implemented fully as the pilot for the testing of institutional reforms were designed for failure as there was no ownership. How the Department of Irrigation will implement the reforms, when these are going to affect their bureaucracy and opportunities for rent seeking,” Dr Shahid inquired.
Siddique Panhwar, president of an alliance district Badin’s tail-end farmers, informed the participants that the tail-end areas of Akram canal suffer severely due to upstream theft of water by the influential landowners. “Landowners in head reaches are enjoying water duty of 20 cusecs for 1000 acres against allocated water duty of 14 cusecs,” Panhwar complained.
Similarly, Manzoor Hussain, president of tail-end farmers of Rangpur canal (district Muzaffargarh) said that the farmers at tail-end outlets are not aware of official warabandi. “In addition to that, farmers in our area were also not aware about their water rights. Indus Consortium’s project ‘improving water governance at local level’, however, it has created a lot of awareness among the farmers,” Manzoor acknowledged.
Khalid Saif, Oxfam Novib’s programme manager water governance, said that the stakeholders should sit together to identify and solve the issues of water users, especially at tail ends. Small farmers should be empowered and taken onboard while developing any policies related to water and agriculture.
Dr Fateh Marri, who heads the World Bank-funded Water Sector Improvement Project (WSIP), said Sindh used to get 90 percent agriculture products through irrigated agriculture, while only 10 percent of the products come from rain-fed, desert and mountainous areas. “Growers want to cultivate entire pieces of land and need more water. Similarly, urbanisation is increasing side by side with increase in population. This has caused decrease in the cultivable land and is affecting water quality and soil fertility, Marri added.
Abdul Majeed Nizamani, president Sindh Abadgar Board, said that Pakistan’s agriculture and in turn economy has tremendous potential to grow, adding that self-sufficiency in the agriculture sector could only be achieved by framing farmer-friendly policies. “Goal of national development and prosperity can only be achieved by taking concrete steps for the uplift of agriculture sector and facilitating farmers, especially the poor ones,” Nizamani said.
Indus Consortium’s executive director Iqbal Hyder urged the Sindh government to give more consideration to the environment and conservation, and to safeguard of individuals’ and tail end farmers’ water rights. Otherwise, Iqbal suggested, by 2030 the situation may become irreversibly critical, and cause mass hunger and malnutrition.
Mushtaq Gaadi, water expert and academician, said the empirical evidence suggests that water productivity of Punjab in comparison to other similar cases is very much low. “The way forward to cope with this crisis and get prepared for future risks, it is imperative adopting dialogic and democratic approach so that the representatives of all old and new actors should be able to participate, confronts and forge consensus,” Gaadi suggested.
Mustafa Ujjan, director Nara Canal Area Water Board, informed the participants that the government institutions have not appreciated and acknowledge public participation in policy framing and decision-making processes. “Alongside the irrigation, provincial water policies should also address other water-related aspects like water for ecology, drainage and environment,” Ujjan emphasised.
Dr Bakhshal Lashari, head of Water Department in Mehran University of Engineering and Technology, said there is potential and expertise in educational institutions such as universities, and that expertise could be utilised. This could be an effective way to sensitise policymakers, he added.-PR
Business Recorder



