High input subsidies creating problems for Pak farmers
LAHORE: Pakistani farmers cannot compete with their Indian counterparts, as the Indian government is providing high subsidies on the agriculture inputs, making the cost of production almost half, officials said on Tuesday.
Main farmer organisations have threatened to launch countrywide movement if the federal government gave a go-ahead to award status of most favoured nation (MFN) to India.
Major growers’ bodies, including Farmers Associates of Pakistan, Sindh Abadgar Board, Agri-Forum Pakistan, Kissan Board Pakistan and Basmati Growers Association have rejected what they called reported unilateral move to give MFN status to India.
Talking to The News, Abdul Majeed Nizamani, President, Sindh Abadgar Board, said that the cost of production of Pakistani farmers is 66 percent less than Indian growers.
There is a marked difference in prices of inputs, including fertiliser, seeds, pesticides, diesel and electricity in both the countries, he said. Hence, he said, there is no comparison between the overall costs of production of farmers living in the two countries.
Talking about wheat crop, Nizamani said, Indian wheat prices hover around Rs850 per 40kg in terms of Pakistani rupee against Rs1,250 that has been calculated in Pakistan for Rabi 2011/12.
Giving another comparison, he said, price of 50kg urea bag in India is just Rs600, while it is not available in Pakistan even at Rs2,000 per bag.
“Due to such multiple factors, we are not capable of compete with India in international, as well as our own market,” he said.
“If we are forced to fight India in the garb of MFN status, while our hands are tied, how we can win? He questioned.
He asked the government to ensure level-playing field to their own farmers before opening trade route with India.
Otherwise, he said, not only farmers of Sindh, Punjab and other provinces would start protest campaign, but they would move court against such irrational decision.
Tariq Bucha, President, FAP, said that Pakistan governments decision to give India the MFN status is unilateral and a step in a hurry without considering the pros and cons.
The federal government should not take and implement this decision without consulting the provinces, he said.
Pakistan’s internal situation, economy, especially the agriculture sector is not capable to compete with the Indian products.
Since inception, the agriculture sector remained neglected and suffered from the lack of investment by the government of Pakistan, he said, adding that India had always given intense importance to its agriculture sector augmented by various subsidies and other incentives.
India annually allocated trillions of rupees, while the Pakistan government spent peanuts on the agriculture sector, said Bucha.
If under the MFN regime, the government of Pakistan allows the Indian agriculture products to be imported, not only Pakistani farmers will be destroyed, but soon India will prevail and take control of the local markets through various typical coercive measures, including water stoppages, resulting in eventual famine-like situation in Pakistan.
The FAP president said that in case of the agriculture economy suffering such adverse shocks, it will affect the industry, as well and already high ratio of unemployment will rise manifold.
If the government of Pakistan is serious in giving the status of most favoured nation to India, it must complete its homework, he said.
“Work on the WTO rules must be completed first. It should read carefully the infrastructure of Indian and Pakistan’s agriculture sector, consult farmer organisations in Pakistan and after due diligence and full preparation take such decision.”
FAP is not against trade with any country, especially with India, but without rules, equal opportunity and the consensus with the stakeholders, ie, farming organisations such as FAP, the MFN status to India will be detrimental, he added.
He warned that if the government will not take the farmers on board they will be compelled to take measures, including blocking agri products imports from India to safeguard the interest of the farming community and the people of Pakistan.
The government of Pakistan should not fall prey to the Indian strategy of sugar coated yet bitter lollipop of the great opportunity of market access to Pakistan to the 1,800 million people of India.
Ibrahim Mughal, Chairman, AFP, said farmers of Pakistan are continuously at receiving end and are forced to run pillar to post in order to make both ends meet.
Pakistani farmers have been victim of wrong government policies, while at the same time, they had to face shortages of water, fertiliser, electricity and diesel, he said.
Not only inputs are being sold at exorbitant prices in Pakistan, but farmers are unable to find them in the market, he said.
Sarfraz Khan, Vice President, KBP, lamented that the present government did not do any homework before starting dialogue with India over the MFN status.
There is no consultation with the stakeholders, including growers, he said and cautioned that such half-backed policies would be counterproductive and would be catastrophic for the agriculture sector of Pakistan.
Hamid Malhi, President, BGA said India was already trying to demolish farming sector of Pakistan.
India had launched an organised effort to grab Pakistani prized agriculture products such as Basmati rice fraudulently, he said.
Wednesday, November 02, 2011





