FBR report seeks phased taxation on agriculture income
KARACHI: A syndicate of senior officials of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) in their research report have recommended imposing in three phases and suggested that Abiana or levies payable on land revenue should be treated as tax credit.
The report suggested that in the first phase the agriculture income should be clubbed with the income from other sources and tax should be calculated on this basis. “Proportionate relief and tax credits shall be granted and total payable tax should be determined under this formula,” said the report, which was recently submitted to the senior management of FBR.
It said in case where there is only agriculture income, the income from other heads of income should be taken as zero and proportionate relief should be given at 80 percent of the entitled relief.
In the second phase the taxation on agriculture can be a withholding tax on the total income received for the sale of agriculture produce.
“The rate of this tax can be 3.5 percent,” the paper suggested.
In the final phase agriculture income can be treated as a separate head and all expenditures incurred on deriving this income can be admitted as expense, the report said.
Agriculture is the back bone of economy of Pakistan contributing almost 22 percent to GDP but its share in tax is less than one percent.
The report said that the issue of agriculture income tax has been raised by taxation department from time to time over the last four decades but had always been shelved on one pretext or another. “It has been argued by landlords that they pay land revenue and Usher and, more importantly, the prices of agriculture commodities are kept artificially low,” it said. “Since colonial era, landlords have acquired immense political power. Obviously they are in a position to block any move towards agriculture tax,” it added.
Recently the high-ups of the ministry of finance, including the federal minister, repeatedly stressed that the agriculture income tax is a provincial subject under the constitution. The report said that provincial assemblies are also dominated by landlords, who always block any such move.
According to the report, feudal class politicians have always opposed agriculture income tax arguing that agriculture is the profession of poor segment of the society and, therefore, it should not be taxed.
“They have basically played their politics very wisely to get their benefits because it is only a small chunk of the land that is with the poor farmers and the major portion of land is with them,” it said.
The report said that exemptions, subsidies and support prices for food items have become a parasite for the economy. “Due to the half-baked economic and political steps the agriculture of Pakistan is characterised by a very low per acre yield for a variety of seed born and soil born diseases, poor seeds, lake of irrigation knowledge, classical farming and absence of research,” it added.
The report recommended that a well-orchestrated programme for agriculture involving the withdrawal of exemptions and subsidies will encourage agriculture production, optimum utilisation of agricultural land, research and innovation in agricultural inputs and practices.
This programme must include soft loans, technical assistance to farmers and agricultural research in agricultural institutes. “It will increase per acre yield and improve nutritional value of food at the one end and exert a pleasant impact on the industry, national and international competitiveness in food market and revenue including tax revenue potential at the other end,” it added.
The report said that the agriculture is always considered as a weak segment of the economy. It further said that in the repealed income tax ordinance the agriculture was used for rate purposes only if a person had income from other sources along with agricultural income while the feudal landlords who declared only agricultural income were exempted.
“More over (ex-president General Pervez) Musharraf was persuaded…. to repeal wealth tax to immune themselves from the wealth tax on their agricultural land and the precious real state,” the report said. “But the exemptions and subsidies have cost a negative effect on agriculture and stifled the progress of this sector despite giving it any boost,” it added.
Agriculture accounted for about 53 percent of GDP in 1947. While per-capita agricultural output has grown since then, it has been outpaced by the growth of the non-agricultural sectors, and the share of agriculture has dropped to roughly one-fifth of Pakistan’s economy.
The report identified that another excuse mostly given for not levying agricultural income tax is the absence of documentation of agriculture and cost benefit analysis consideration.
“We think it is perhaps the most documented sector of the country as we have a much protected record of even a single Marla of agricultural land,” it added.
FBR officials in their report recommended that an agricultural tax committee consisting of all the stakeholders should be constituted to deliberate upon the issue deeply and seriously.
“It should be made mandatory for the committee to come with practical solution with in a rational duration of time because it is already too late.”
The News
Incoming search terms:
- fbr pakistan





