Farmers, experts sceptical about benefit of crops insurance scheme
The government has allocated Rs 2.5 billion in the budget of 2014-15 for the crop loan insurance scheme, but farmers and experts remain skeptical about the implementation of the scheme. Sarfaraz Ahmad Khan, Kisan Board chairman, told Business Recorder on Tuesday that the scheme was useless as the government has no strategy to reach the subsistent level farmers.
“Such schemes are designed solely to get political mileage,” he said pointing out flaws in the scheme. He said the farmers could not benefit from the scheme until the government declared an area calamity-hit. “The farmers who get a loan from Zari Taraqiati Bank are charged two percent extra interests for an insurance scheme, but their grievances are never addressed,” he said.
During the budget speech Finance Minister Ishaq Dar said that all farmers obtaining loans for production of five major crops would be eligible to benefit from the scheme. “About 700,000 farmer households/families will benefit from the scheme. Total budget cost of the scheme is Rs 2.5 billion,” he said. In the budget, the scope of crop insurance premium reimbursement was enhanced from 12.5 acres to 25 acres of land.
Giving statistics about the small farmers, Sarfaraz Khan said around 91 percent of farmers in Pakistan have a land holding of up to 25 acres and they should be looked after in a better way by the government. “If the government wants to make the insurance scheme a success story, then it should introduce the scheme on yield basis instead of damage to the crops,” he suggested.
He pointed out that the government has not designed any specific evaluation criteria for the insurance scheme for small farmers. “The schemes are always geared to benefit small farmers, but ultimately they end up benefiting the progressive farmers,” he said. Dr Pervaiz Amir, an environmental expert and former chief of Prime Minister’s Task Force on Climate Change, said the insurance schemes have been announced in the past as well with much fanfare but ultimately they proved to be unimplementable. “How can small farmers afford the premium,” he questioned, suggesting that the government should provide loans to farmers at minimal interest rate instead of favouring gimmicks.
He said the crop insurance scheme has always been abused by officials as there has been no specific mechanism to settle claims. “It is ridiculous that a farmer cannot claim his insurance until the government declares his area as calamity-hit,” he said. Dr Amir suggested the government should ensure better market access for the farmers guarantee good price for their produce and support efforts to increase production of crops to facilitate subsistence farmers.
“There is also an element of religion in the insurance scheme,” he said, adding “people don’t get life insurance, let alone crop insurance.” Muhammad Rizwanullah, Senior Vice President at ZTBL, told Business Recorder that around 1.2 million subsistence farmers have benefited from the scheme in the last five years.
Admitting flaws in the scheme, he said that if an area was hit by some kind of disaster, the ZTBL got 300 percent indemnity from the insurance company for the area, but the amount was distributed among all borrowers. “This is true the farmers never get the full claim for their insured crops,” he said, adding the ZTBL cannot improve the system on its own as the bank serves only as a liaison between the State Bank of Pakistan and the insurance companies.
Business Recorder
Related articles across the web




