Environmental issues in sharing water resources
RAPID population growth, urbanisation and unsustainable water consumption practices have placed immense stress on the quality as well as quantity of water resources in the country.
The per capita water availability has decreased from 5,000 cubic metres per annum in 1951 to 1,100. Deterioration in water quality and contamination of lakes, rivers and groundwater aquifers has resulted in increased waterborne diseases and other health impacts.
Water is a sensitive issue and it is not easy to bring key stakeholders to deliberate on this crucial issue. However, recently, two parallel dialogues were held on issues in water resources management. One was convened by the IUCN and the other by PILDAT.
The IUCN was able to bring together water stalwarts at a single forum to discuss four policy briefs including (i) Indus Water Treaty and Managing Shared Water Resources for the Benefit of Basin States, (ii) Beyond Indus Water Treaty: Groundwater and Environmental Management, (iii) Towards Kabul Water Treaty: Managing Shared Water Resources, and (iv) Pakistan Water Apportionment Accord for Resolving Inter-provincial water disputes.
Though all four policy briefs were discussed in detail, the fourth paper, which deals with 1991 water accord, received much attention in deliberations.
The key messages drawn from the discourse were to promote science-based research free from any bias, as subsequently facts would lead to trust building in present trust- deficit scenario. Fact book on water be developed and updated; this could only be possible, if Wapda could share the data candidly.
According to policy brief, the upper riparian have the tendency to take the larger share of water in times of shortage and have difficulty in accepting the rights of lower riparian in sharing the water shortages equitably. Hence, it is very much clear that water distribution is a concern during period of short ages, whereas during period of excess, the lower riparian will receive most of the floodwater.
The lower riparian is in fact a victim in both the extremes. This can be witnessed from 2010 floods, which heavily affected the lower riparian parts of the country. Moreover, lower riparian also receive all sorts of effluents, which affect the biodiversity and ecology of the area.
The brief points out that Sindh being lower riparian is not in favour of any dam on Indus. The fear is that the detrimental consequences of diminished water supply already experienced by Sindh, inflow of seawater, loss of agricultural land to desertification, loss of livelihoods, shrinking of the mangrove forests, deterioration in water quality and health problems will be exacerbated. So far, the debate has been around downstream Kotri but a lower riparian part of southern Punjab and area below Guddu barrage has also been affected by low flow in the Indus.
In March 1991, the four provinces came to an agreement about distribution of water of Indus under the Indus Water Accord. The Indus Water Accord recognises that flows of fresh water to the delta are vital to the maintenance of the mangrove ecosystem and a provisional 10 MAF was agreed upon.
The IUCN gave its first reaction to 1991 water accord through its study titled possible impacts of water accord on the Indus delta. It recommended that till the study is conducted to determine water requirements, 27 MAF should be released to the Indus delta. Whereas, the quantity of even 10 MAF provisionally allocated under the 1991 ac cord is also hardly available.
The historical flow of water into the delta region was over 170 MAF per year. This quantum kept the 17 main creeks and a multitude of minor creeks active, and maintained a balance between seawater and freshwater in the tidal zones. The survival of the Indus delta is dependent on the silt laden freshwater discharge from the Indus River, which has been curtailed due to diversion of water for agriculture, power generation and other uses in the upper reaches.
The freshwater flows into the delta during the recent years have been inconsistent and mostly below the minimum required quantity. Most of the inhabitants of deltaic region are fisherfolk who fish in river, estuaries, lakes and creeks and their livelihood is mainly dependent on natural resources.
Apart from fresh water fisheries, about 200 fish species have been recorded from the delta region. Export of fisheries resource contributes almost two per cent of the total national exports, amounting to Rs8.8 billion annually. Of the total export, shrimp contributes 60 per cent while the rest 40 per cent is from fish. Besides fishing, many coastal people were engaged in agriculture and livestock rearing but due to water scarcity their livelihood is in jeopardy.
Fresh river water flowing into the sea brings many benefits. It maintains salinity in the estuaries, allowing aquatic life to flourish and maintain a balanced eco-system. The continuous reduction in fresh water inflow below Kotri Barrage is resulting in salt water intrusion, changes in the geomorphology of the delta and nutrient imbalance of the ecosystem.
If the volume of freshwater is large enough, it can push seawater away from the river mouth. Hence, in rivers with a long duration of high flows, freshwater is able to prevent seawater from intruding into the river.There are number of studies undertaken on the deteriorating situation of Indus delta by WWF and IUCN as the delta is also Ramsar site.
Till the four provinces arrive on consensus with regard to figure of water to be released below Kotri, the devastating affects continue to damage the deltaic area. If we are serious to protect the Indus delta then it should be decaled as fifth shareholder of 1991 water accord, besides four provinces.
New concepts like environmental flows are not part of water accords and treaties. An environmental flow is the water regime provided within a river, wetland or coastal zone to maintain ecosystems and their benefits where there are competing water uses and where flows are regulated. Environmental flows provide critical contributions to river health, economic development and poverty alleviation.
NAsir Ali Panhwar [DAWN]
Incoming search terms:
- water resources
- su kaynakları
- water resources pictures
- водные ресурсы
- pictures of water resources
- water resource
- Water Resources of Pakistan
- water resources in pakistan
- per capita water consumption in pakistan
- water





