• Home
  • About Us
  • News Letter
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising
  • Strategic Partners
  • Site Map
  • Privacy Policy
Thursday, April 19th
Agriculture Corner
  • AGRI NEWS
    • Global News
    • National News
    • More News
  • CROPS
    • Cotton
    • Maize
    • Rice
    • Sugarcane
    • Wheat
  • HORTICULTURE
    • FRUITS
      • Mango
      • Citrus
      • Apple
    • VEGETABLES
      • Cabbage
      • Caulifower
      • Onion
      • Potato
    • FLOWERS
      • Bulbs
      • Jasmine
      • Rose
  • KNOWLEDGE CENTER
    • mAgricorner
    • Agribusiness
    • Alternative Energy
    • Weather
    • Education
    • Hot Topics
    • ICT4D
    • Jobs & Scholorships
    • Model Farming
    • WareHousing
    • Farm Advisory
  • LIVE STOCK
    • Dairy
    • Poultry
  • Urdu
Agriculture Corner -Empowering farmers with best information through ICT4Ag

Download Free Mobile App

Join US

Register With Us / Newsletter

Register as AGRICULTURE Farmer / Businessmen / Expert / Professional / Student & get latest info in your mail box . 4,200 Subscribers as on March, 2016

  • Most Commented
  • Most Viewed
  1. Solar tube-well installation: 'government to give 80 percent subsidy' 104 comments
  2. Scholarships available students to do MSc agricultural extension program 74 comments
  3. Initiatives for olive plantation in Pakistan 59 comments
  4. Masters and PhD Scholarship in Agriculture for African Countries, Australia 2012-2013 46 comments
  5. Installation of solar water pumps: Punjab government recommends Rs 300 million allocations 31 comments
  1. Solar tube-well installation: ‘government to give 80 percent subsidy’ 32303 views
  2. Production Status Of Major Vegetables In Pakistan, Their Problems And Suggestions 27767 views
  3. Agriculture Growth: Pakistan Economic Survey 2012-13 21841 views
  4. Grain and other commodity rates in rupees on Akbari Mandi on Tuesday (April 08, 2014) 18404 views
  5. MTL increases tractors’ price second time in six months 15288 views

Follow Agriculture Corner

Advertise here

Place your brand here. info[at]agricorner.com

Web Stats February-2016:
Registered Member : 4,200
Sessions: 12,500
Page Views: 18,700

Top Locations :
Pakistan: 32%
USA: 23%
India: 15%

Pakistan Economic Survey

Economic Survey 2014-15

Economic Survey 2013-14

Economic Survey 2012-13

Real Time Commodities Quotes


The Commodity Prices Powered by Investing.com

Agriculture Corner Forum

Join Agriculture Corner Yahoo Forum mailing list to receive the daily commodities write up, Daily Commodity closing, Periodic Global Agriculture Reports about Production, Consumption, Trade; Developments in Agriculture Innovation, Mobile Agriculture, and lot more stuff;
Join Agriculture Corner

Social Widget

  • RSS Feed RSS FeedSubscribe Now
  •  EmailContact Us
  •  TwitterFollow Us
  •  FacebookAdd Us
 

Archives

Join us on Facebook

You are here: Home » CROPS » Sugarcane »

Despite surplus sugar, consumers burdened with 25% subsidy

October 16, 2017 6:48 am 0 comments Views: 20

Share this Article

  • TwitterTwitter
  • FacebookFacebook
  • DeliciousDelicious
  • DiggDigg
  • StumbleuponStumble
  • RedditReddit

Related Posts

  • Govt allows sugar export, sets conditions for subsidy
  • Dollar depreciation: ‘sugar export restricted to 0.4 million tons’
  • Problematic surplus sugar

sugarKARACHI: Pakistan is among top 10 sugarcane producing countries of the world. We produce almost 50 million tons of sugarcane, which is converted into 5-7 million tons of sugar on an annual basis. Almost 89 sugar mills operate in the country and these mills are spread all across Pakistan.

Despite being one of the major producers of this commodity, the prices of sugar are relatively high for local consumers.

Furthermore, this year a surplus stock was accumulated and almost one million tons of sugar was stashed in warehouses (godowns). Millers have negotiated export deals but only with the support of Rs10 per kg subsidy. They are exporting at prices ranging from Rs40-43 per kg and collecting a subsidy.

This means that Pakistani retail prices are at least Rs10 per kg higher than the rest of the world. This translates into an almost 25% subsidy.

So we can rephrase the problem in the following words:

Pakistan witnessed a bumper crop this year and our yields have improved. Under normal rules of supply and demand, a surplus would have accumulated and the consumers should have got the same commodity at lower prices.

Instead of this, consumers are getting sugar at higher prices and to dispose of the surplus stock, consumers/taxpayers are also bearing the burden of 25% subsidy.

Why are we consuming such expensive sugar? And why are we paying a subsidy to dispose it off whereas it can’t be given to us at lower prices? These figures are baffling.

The real problem doesn’t lie in the figures cited above. These figures are the tip of the iceberg. The real problem lies with the sugarcane prices that are not regulated or determined by the market.

According to the statistics presented by the Pakistan Sugar Mills Association, the support price for sugarcane has increased from Rs20 per maund to Rs180 per maund from 1994-95 to 2016 whereas retail sugar prices have increased from Rs14 to Rs62 in the corresponding period.

This means the price of the primary raw material increased by almost nine times whereas the selling price increased by 4.4 times only.

Hence, keeping all other variables constant, the increase in prices of raw material is more than double the increase in selling price. Therefore, the consumers and the millers are on the losing end in the last 25 years.

The high sugarcane prices have eliminated the incentive to improve for our farmers also. We might be helping them in the short run but in the long run we are making them uncompetitive in comparison to international competition.

Evidence of this long-term lack of competitiveness can be seen from comparatively lower yields of our sugarcane crop. Yield per hectare in Pakistan in 2016 was 58 tons, which is almost 26% less than Brazil (market leader) of 73 tons.

Subsidising sugar in itself is a big debate altogether. Giles Fraser, an eminent journalist, wrote an article in the Guardian on July 13, 2017 titled; “Sugar is poison. My heart attack has finally opened my eyes to the truth”.

In this article, he has substantiated that in the US, the sugar industry and their offshoots have manipulated research into heart diseases to underplay the role of sugar behind heart diseases. Hence, policymakers must be cognisant of this fact and must consider prioritising other avenues like health and education with positive externalities for channelling extremely scarce subsidy funds.

The current sugar export policy will definitely bring in valuable foreign exchange. This is something which must be appreciated as far as the balance of payments correction is considered.

However, for long-term increase in exports of sugar, we must correct the structural imbalances. This cannot be done in a couple of years. This requires policymaking with a long-term horizon in perspective. We need to incentivise our farmers to improve yields so that we can match our international competition.

To sum it up, Pakistani sugar is expensive for the local consumers. Furthermore, these consumers are also the taxpayers and these taxpayers are paying extra money for disposing of surplus stock.

Hence, our policymakers must also consider the interest of consumers and devise a long-term policy for correcting structural deficiencies so that the consumers also get sugar at or around international prices, our farmers produce better crop at competitive prices and the millers also get their lost margins.

Source: The Express Tribune

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.


  • Home
  • About Us
  • News Letter
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising
  • Strategic Partners
  • Site Map
  • Privacy Policy
© Copyright 2018 — Agriculture Corner. All Rights Reserved