Deadlock over cane rate
ONLY eight sugar mills had started cane crushing till Thursday due to short supply of cane. All except one of the 32 functional sugar mills of Sindh were to start crushing by November 1 — the date notified by the provincial government. But by November 3, only six had started crushing. Another 15 could only fire their boilers. This is because a deadlock persists between the two major stakeholders — millers and growers — over cane price.
While growers have serious reservations over support price of Rs127 per 40kg, management of various sugar mills say that they are incurring unnecessary expenditures as they are forced to light and shut down their boilers amidst short supply of cane. The growers are not ready to supply cane to mills below Rs300Rs400 per 40kg.
When price of sugar in the market was Rs40 per kg last year, sugarcane support price was fixed at Rs102 but the growers had supplied cane between Rs250 and Rs300. Some of them say that since they got better price for cotton crop in Kharif they are not in any haste to harvest cane regardless of the fact that wheat cultivation was being delayed. Wheat is cultivated after the harvest of cane.
“We can wait for some more time to harvest our crop because abadgars get attractive price for cotton crop. Given the current sugar price at Rs100 to Rs115 per kg in market, we deserve fair price for our crop which should be between Rs300 and Rs400,” claimed Azizullah Memon, president of Small Growers Association (SGA) Tando Allahyar district where only Mehran Sugar Mill is located. He has supplied cane to Mehran as well as Mirpurkhas and Tharparkar sugar mills of Mirpurkhas district. The Sindh government should have fixed the price at least at Rs150 per 40kg instead of Rs127, he said.
Growers expect that sugar mills would start offering better rates than the support price after Eidul Azha as crushing season proceeds.
Sindh Abadgar Board President Abdul Majeed Nizamani, while discussing current deadlock over supply of cane crop, relies on the statement of a mill owner from Punjab who says mill owners should offer Rs200 per 40kg to growers because by December and January sugar price would be Rs70 per kg. “My assessment is that average price of sugar will be around 85 per kg which means that growers should get support price of more than Rs200,” he said.
Reports also indicate that mills are persuading growers to harvest their crop to get adequate cane supply. According to managements, mills are suspending crushing for want of cane or they are operating mills after every 48 hours, taking a 24 hours break. This raises their cost of production.
Cane Manager of Mirpurkhas Sugar Mills, Mohammad Ibrahim says that so far 60,000 maunds of cane has been crushed in the mills which started crushing on November 5 with a daily crushing capacity of 120,000 maunds. “By November 10, we should have crushed 400,000 maunds of cane”, he said.
Sindh Chamber of Agriculture’s representative Dr Nadeem Qamar believes that the tug of war between the growers and millers is the outcome of unrealistic support price for cane.. “The government can’t enforce a writ when such decisions are taken without proper consultation among stakeholders,” he lamented. He said sugar price in the international markets has gone up sharply and the current support price of cane is unacceptable and should not have been below Rs200 per 40kg.
Mehran Sugar Mills in Tando Allahyar started crushing on October 29 and one of its mangers Ehtesham said that by Wednesday only 200,000 maunds of cane was crushed against its daily capacity of 230,000 maunds. “We haven’t produced even one kilogram of sugar as yet and the same is the case with sugar mills in neighbouring Mirpurkhas district,” he said.
The millers believe that cane growers are influenced by the current sugar crisis in which the price of sweetener has touched Rs110 and Rs120 per kg; that’s why they feel that millers would be offering them more than Rs200 for 40 kg cane soon. They said that last year Rs250 was offered to growers in February when crushing was going to be closed. They are confident that post Eidul Azha crushing would gain momentum because growers cannot afford delaying the harvest of cane further as it would start losing weight.
By Mohammad Hussain Khan [DAWN]
Incoming search terms:
- sugar transport



