Beneficiaries of wheat subsidy
THE commencement of the official wheat procurement season in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa a few weeks ago has put the provincial government under pressure. While the government has a wheat storage capacity of 354,000 tonnes, the provincial directorate of food will procure 400,000 tonnes this year — about 100,000 tonnes more than last year.
“The federal government has advised us to store more wheat this year,” an official told Dawn.
Therefore, authorities will need to arrange extra warehouses to store the additional wheat. In doing so, they might also need to spend money to ensure that any private warehouses that they rent meet hygiene and quality standards. The provincial government will also be spending more money on transporting wheat to official warehouses in far-off, wheat-deficient areas.
And since Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) government is required to procure an additional 100,000 tonnes this year, it would be borrowing more money from commercial banks to be able to meet the procurement target. As a result, it will see its costs on interest payments go up this year as well.
For a population of around 32 million people, which includes 1.5 million Afghan refugees, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa requires around 3.9 million tonnes of wheat every year to meet its wheat flour consumption requirements.
Against this, the province would only procure around 400,000 tonnes this year — less than 10 per cent of the requirement.
The provincial government’s subsidy on wheat will also register an increase this year, due to the higher procurement target. It spent Rs2 billion last year on subsidy on wheat supplied from official stocks to flour mills. And while the provincial government had allocated Rs2.5 billion for wheat subsidy in its budget for this financial year, the amount was based on last year’s procurement data. The actual subsidy bill is expected to go over Rs3.5 billion.
“We have not yet calculated the subsidy amount,” said a concerned official.
The subsidy is meant to benefit the consumers of wheat flour. However, that has never been the case, and the money spent on subsidy ends up in the pockets of strong clique of transporters, flour mill owners and unscrupulous officials. In some cases in the past, political bigwigs running the provincial food ministry had also made money out of subsidies.
Officials say the subsidy is meant to keep prices under control, ensure supply of wheat to flour mills during the eight-month lean period (from September to April), when wheat supplies in the open market are thinner.
The official policy becomes effective only when there is a shortage of wheat in the open market. Pakistan has recorded bumper wheat crops during the past few years. As a result, there have hardly been any wheat shortages in the open market.
This is also evident from the fact that the provincial government’s food controllers have a wide variety of sellers to choose from. But they prefer to buy wheat from large groups in Punjab, instead of from local small farmers. These small farmers should form the priority for KP’s food controllers, but they sell their produce in local open markets that are largely manipulated by middlemen and smalltime commission agents.
The provincial government, according to an official, has set up 18 wheat procurement centres in different parts of the province. So far, only those in Dera Ismail Khan, Sara-i-Naurang, Kohat, and Peshawar have started procurement. Dera Ismail Khan’s centre has procured 14,000 tonnes at a time when thousands of small farmers have already sold their produce in the local market at a cost lower than the officially fixed wheat support price.
Umer Khan, a farmer from Koolachi tehsil of Dera Ismail Khan district, told Dawn that he had sold his harvest at around Rs2,800 per 100 kilogramme, which is Rs200 lower than the official wheat support price. He did not take his wheat produce to the official wheat procurement centre because, he claimed, it was not cost effective for him. And the official system is too cumbersome for small farmers.
In the far off, land-locked mountainous Chitral district, wheat flour requirements are largely met through supplies of the end commodity — atta — from down the country, than the marginal wheat supplies that come from official warehouses. The district does not have a single modern flour mill.
Locally produced wheat and supplies from official warehouses are utilised to get wheat flour at indigenous flour mills operated by watermills. Nonetheless, the market is dumped with wheat flour supplied from down the country. Hence, the government money spent on subsidy is of no use to the end users.
Dawn
Incoming search terms:
- what is a wheat subsidy



