AS optimism grows for a ‘bumper wheat crop’ in Punjab, farmers’ fears grow alongside for possible price fluctuations
Till last week, Punjab was expecting around 18 million tonnes yield.
Lately, its estimate has risen to 18.64 million tonnes, with a record average of 30.89 maunds per acre. Even that tally might see some upwards revision when harvesting and thrashing — delayed by two weeks due to weather variables (rains and temperature) — gains momentum.
The Space and Upper Atmosphere Research Commission (Suparco) was first to indicate the crop size, which now seems to have become a reality. Basing its estimation on satellite imagery, it put the crop size at huge 19.51 million tonnes in Punjab.
Taking multiple positive factors into account during this Rabi, it projected a crop size, which no one believed till two weeks ago.
It noted abundant supplies of phosphate fertilisers and well distributed rains (nine times during December to February period).
The phosphate led to a growth and proliferation of root system, allowing better moisture absorption and formation of starches, enlarging grain size and weight, leading to an increase in crop yield.
The rains covered critical heat growth stages of tillering, booting, flagging, earring, grain filling and maturity. Given all these positive developments, the country is predicted to harvest 26.207 million tonnes of wheat of which 19.513 million tonnes will come from Punjab.
Now, as the crop size inches closer to the Suparco scenario, everyone is keeping his fingers crossed, especially the farmers. The trouble for them can spring from a few factors that bumper crop and its arrival pattern in the market would create.
An almost two-week delay in harvesting would mean crop arrival time will be reduced correspondingly. An unprecedented size of crop would land in the market in four, instead of six, weeks — leading to glut and all allied consequences for wheat trade, traders and farmers.
Another factor is relatively smaller target; in terms of crop size, whenever the crop yield inched closer to 19 million tonnes, even six million tonnes purchase by the department has not helped. Traditionally, at least for planning purposes, 30 per cent of crop is considered to be tradable surplus.
This calculation needs some revision as consumption pattern changes: cities have grown huge and most of the labour comes from rural areas — generating reverse flow of flour. This labour takes flour back to villages from the cities where this staple is
subsidised to facilitate city dwellers.
Thus, this surplus, by all means has grown substantially, but has not been documented so far, creating anomaly in planning.
With crop size growing much bigger than routine, even that 30 per cent would grow in quantitative terms — keeping the market unstable from farmers’ perspective.
The Food Department’s procurement policy pattern, divided in three fortnights might not help the market either. The department plans to procure 60 per cent of four million tonnes target in first 15 days; 25 per cent in the next two weeks and 15 per cent in the last fortnight. That means first 15 days would see it purchasing 2.4 million tonnes. It should certainly be a
stabilising factor. But next fortnight might see a slide in price, worsening in the next last two weeks when the millers and middle-men, motivated by profiteering, will go slow on purchase, letting the glut cumulate and price slide. So, the last four weeks might be testing for farmers.
To their misfortune, during most of procurement campaign, the caretaker set-up would be in-charge, riveted on ensuring free and fair elections and pushing procurement a few notches down the priority list. In the last few years, the district coordination officers (DCOs) have grown important with regards to wheat procurement.
The department and provincial government are mainly restricted to arranging finances and preparing overall policy; actual execution depends upon the DCOs. Almost all of them are new in their districts because of massive pre-election reshuffling and assigned to ensure peaceful and free and fair elections. The wheat trade would thus largely be left to the market forces, putting the farmers at a disadvantage.
The world wheat realities, which kept the crop in high demand entire last year, are not very encouraging either. Wheat prices though still hovering around $300 per ton are sliding. With positive projections for the Russian, Ukrainian and Australian crops, prices might continue sliding – taking financial sheen off the crop this year and keeping the big investors away.
However, on a positive note, the current release price of the department (Rs1,125 per 40Kg) and the next one in September
would have an unprecedented margin of more than Rs125 per 40Kg. The department, which is purchasing at Rs1,200 per 40Kg, would be selling it at a minimum price of Rs1,250 per 40Kg to the millers.
The huge price difference might encourage middlemen and some investors, who are eyeing domestic market, into aggressive
buying. This margin has traditionally ranged from Rs50 to Rs75 per 40Kg. This year, it may swell beyond the above-mentioned figure in case of crash. It would, however, can also be a cause of crash as the middlemen and investor would go slower in their purchase to let glut worsen and price fall.
So far, only 28 per cent harvesting has been completed in the province, and thrashing even less at seven per cent. But with some districts, like Khanewal and Okara, already crossing average yield of 40 maunds per acre, crop expectations are defeating all previous calculations. The expected momentum in arrivals in the market may set the price trend.
Dawn



