An eventual rise in SA food prices is inevitable
Volatility in prices has harmed SA farmers. Measuresto protect SA agriculture make sense in the long run
Lessons learnt during the “global food crisis” of 2008 could be put to good use as the world faces up to even higher prices this year.
The UN Food & Agriculture Organisation (FAO) has presented a number of measures that countries which may be confronted with spiralling food inflation could consider to lessen the negative effects on vulnerable populations.
For SA, the strong rand and huge grain surpluses — that SA is, for infrastructural reasons, unable to export — has to some extent shielded the country from the worst effects of the higher world prices. But it is unclear how long that scenario will prevail. Agricultural economists agree that the high prices will eventually filter through to SA.
The FAO’s food price index surpassed the 30-year highs of 2008 last month as unfavourable weather, currency fluctuations and unsuitable policy responses by some exporting countries led to unexpected shortfalls in supply.
The organisation admits that its proposed interventions come with economic risks and costs that must be taken into account, but feels they present a good basis from which government and the farming and food industries could start a debate on how to avoid the worst impact of food inflation.
In its list of measures governments could implement to tackle the issue, the FAO urges countries to organise broad national consultation mechanisms . This, it says, would help to sidestep the inevitable mistrust that arises between private-sector traders, governments, farmers and consumers at times of high prices.
SA will be familiar with this scenario: in 2008 accusations over who was responsible and who was benefiting most from high food prices flew back and forth. “Ideally,” the FAO says, “the population should be informed of decisions taken throughout this process through the media.”
The FAO makes it clear that countries should be selective in the actions they choose as conditions will vary from country to country. It suggests:
Banning exports of strategic food commodities should be avoided because of the serious negative effects this is likely to have, “both in-country and abroad”.
It is a course that many countries took in 2008, and Russia last year when drought and fires cut its grain production. One effect of such a strategy is to push producer prices down and thereby reduce production. It also creates incentives for food smuggling, and therefore higher prices.
Reducing import taxes on food, agricultural inputs and equipment. Many countries did this in 2008 to limit price increases. A reduction of import duty on inputs such as fertiliser and machinery has been found to increase agricultural productivity , says the FAO. Tax breaks for importers would improve food availability for domestic consumers.
Simplified customs procedures would reduce trade costs and speed up imports, should food inflation hit. Unlike other possible steps, this would have the added bonus of limited implications for the country’s budget.
The suggestion of removal of value-added tax (Vat ) on food seems a reasonable solution to immediately reduce prices. However, in conditions of low competition, it runs the risk that retailers may simply pocket the reduction.
The FAO says if a decision were taken to remove Vat, monitoring of prices and possibly the imposition of fines for retailers who did not pass on lower taxes would have to be introduced.
The removal of road taxes and tax reductions on fuel for transport is another FAO suggestion. In a vast country such as SA, transport costs between farms, food processors, retailers’ warehouses and shops contribute a great deal to food prices. If implemented, this might be beneficial in fighting food inflation.
But it would be difficult to exempt only food products from road taxes, particularly when food transportation may be mixed with other commodities. Such a system would have to be closely monitored.
Fuel taxes in SA are an important source of government revenue and that would make such measures difficult to sell.
Seizing private food stocks and obliging owners to sell them, though increasing immediate availability is not recommended. It would result in problems in future with, perhaps, owners hiding their stocks or even being reluctant to build them up.
Progressive releases of food kept in public food reserves, as done in Burkina Faso in 2008, could reduce price hikes and assist more vulnerable people.
“Though food stocks worldwide are at their lowest levels in decades, there are some reserves at country level … that can be progressively released either on the market to help keep prices down, or in the form of food distribution to those unable to buy on the market,” says the FAO. In SA, the huge maize surplus might represent an opportunity for creative action by government.
Another measure if food inflation were to get out of hand would be the transfer of cash or food vouchers to vulnerable households. Such a strategy could have mixed effects and create opportunities for corruption.
In Brazil, cash is transferred to households in exchange for children’s attendance at school and visits to clinics.
Contract farming could be something that SA might consider, particularly with farmers new to the sector. Contracts through which farmers would agree to supply quantities of food in exchange for technical support and credit means some of the risk would be removed from farming. Government would provide an assured market for the food.
The FAO’s proposals were sceptically received by agricultural economists.
John Lishman, Nedbank’s head of agriculture, says the recommendations are largely “short-term solutions” that would not solve inherent problems. Lishman believes a free-market approach would sort out the problems and ensure efficient food production.
“I’m tired of role players looking for short-term solutions which just interfere with the market and keep inefficient producers in business.”
In SA, the long-term answer to food shortages and high prices is the adoption of a policy framework that drives investment in agriculture.
“We must control what we can — getting land reform sorted out, providing support for emerging farmers and investing in our agriculture sector,” he says.
Tariffs to protect SA producers against subsidised imports should not be ruled out, he says.
Standard Bank agricultural banking director Willie du Plessis says it is inevitable that higher food inflation will filter through to domestic markets soon. Higher food prices would be a blow to a large proportion of the SA population but Du Plessis says in reality food prices are too low.
Prices need to provide farmers with a margin that allows them to make a living and invest in their businesses.
Shannon Sherry




