16 mills accused of stocking sugar to suppress sales
Sixteen sugar mills in Sindh are accused of stocking 770,538MT sugar worth Rs33.7 billion to suppress sales, following a low sugar ex-mill price since November, it was learnt here on Saturday. According to sources, Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has posted its officers at all 28 sugar mills across Sindh to monitor sugar production under section 40-B of Sales Tax Act 1990, adding that the decision was made after detecting serious discrepancies in their financial ledgers.
The field formation had directed to submit a report on sugar production in order to ascertain the facts behind a severe dip in the revenue collection in sugar sector, which is up to 80 percent.
Moreover, sources said that a weekly monitoring report submitted by the field formation revealed that some 16 sugar mills had reportedly stocked 770,538MT sugar worth Rs 33.7 billion so as to suppress its sales.
They said this practice was aimed at evading federal excise duty (FED) that would ultimately create an impact on sugar mills” annual income. Sources further said that the FBR would take action to collect a substantial amount of FED from these sugar mills against the said stock.
On the other hand, the amount of tax refunds in tax year 2013 was 150 percent higher than tax payments, showing an alarming performance wherein tax refund claims were over Rs550 million against tax payables of over Rs350 million.
They said that one of the reasons behind such revenue decline might be the sale price of sugar which was as high as Rs88 per kg in November 2011, but later it decreased to Rs 50 per kg. However, the production cost per kg was reported over Rs 60.
Moreover, they said that the sugar price had declined in tax year-2013, but most of the sugar mills had consistently been declaring huge losses since tax year-2010, casting doubts on returns of sugar mills.
They said that sustainability of these sugar mills declaring huge losses even during a sugar price boom during 2011 raised questions about the declared version of these sugar mills and there might be suppression of sales by the sugar mills.
They said tax turnover ratio of sugar sector was less than one percent during 2013 and its decline might have occurred, due to a facility availed under SRO 77(I)/2013.
They said that SRO 77(I)/2013 allowed reduced rate at 0.5 percent FED instead of eight percent on local sale of white crystalline sugar equivalent to the quantity actually exported by sugar manufacturer as per quota allotted by Economic Co-ordination Committee (ECC) in its meeting held on January 10, 2013.
This concession of reduced rate was available only on an equivalent quantity of local sale of sugar on supplies made in the tax period succeeding the tax period in which the export took place.
Further concession/relief was also allowed through SRO 1072 (I)/2013 by amending SRO 77(I)/2013, whereby the registered person might charge FED at reduced rate of 0.5 percent on local supply of sugar made in three tax periods succeeding the tax period in which the export took place.
They said that current domestic price of sugar was approximately Rs50/kg ($510/ton), which is linked with international market prices, at around $537/ton.
Pakistan”s production cost of sugar, however, is reported to be around Rs63/kg ($642/ton). On March 6, 2013, the Economic Co-ordination Committee of the Cabinet approved an inland freight subsidy of Rs1.75/kg ($18/ton) for the export of up to 1.2 million tons of sugar. Federal Board of Revenue lowered the Federal Excise Duty on domestic sugar sales from 8.0 percent to 0.5 percent, contingent on each mill”s exports up to its government allocated export quota.
This means that for every ton of sugar exported, the mill would receive a reduction in the excise tax on an equivalent volume sold domestically, up to its export quota.
These concessions were granted at the request of the Pakistan Sugar Mills Association (PSMA) based upon a plea that large production surpluses, high input costs, and increased international competition caused a significant reduction in sugar mills” profits.
In order to ascertain the facts behind this revenue dip in sugar sector, the FBR has posted its officers at all sugar mills in Sindh to monitor sugar production under section 40-B of Sales Tax Act 1990, according to sources.
Business Recorder
Related articles across the web



